Individual Liberty or Social Liberty
Idan wants six hundred acres and no neighbors. Alan points at the wire, the boots, and the words Idan thinks in. A boy found in the Aveyron woods, cattlemen's brand books, a Swiss meadow under written rule since 1483, and a party built to be taken over.
Click to enlarge
Idan Rednaxus and Alan Forester-Kaiser have had this argument for years, usually at a gate. This one is set at a gate too, on a county road, with a cattle guard across it and a sign that reads No Trespassing. The conversation is constructed, and each speaks for a position this collection has heard from both sides.
Idan: Look at that place. Six hundred acres, a well, a house, and nobody within three miles. That’s the argument.
Alan: Which argument?
Idan: The American Liberty people have it half right. Strip the party, the platform, the tariffs, the demands, what’s left is a man who wants to be left alone. Rothbard said it plainest. Each person owns self. Nobody owns him, he owns nobody. Everything after that is a request to be exempt from somebody’s framework.
Alan: The party isn’t a request to be left alone. It’s a request for a convention hall.
Idan: Tools. Use them, drop them.
Alan: Let’s stay on the ranch first. Tell me what’s on it.
Idan: A house, a barn, a well, a herd.
Alan: Who made the wire on that fence?
Idan: A mill somewhere.
Alan: And the steel, and the staples, and the truck that carried it up this road, and the road. The boots on his feet, the rifle, the pump on the well. The rancher lives on this land the way a tenant lives in a house, and every part of it came by an interface. He sends money one direction and gets wire the other, and he never meets the man at the mill. That’s what a framework does when it works. It lets him forget it’s there.
Idan: Exchange. Two people, a price, done. No framework.
Alan: Mises wouldn’t say that. Human Action opens its chapter on society with “Society is concerted action, cooperation.” He didn’t write that cooperation was an exception that exchange makes to individual life. He wrote that it was what life consisted of.
Idan: Cooperation, yes. Voluntary. I never denied cooperation. I deny being told by somebody what to cooperate in.
Alan: Then we agree about the wire. We disagree about whether the mill, the road and the price had to come from somewhere.
What he’d know alone
Alan: In January of 1800, hunters in the Aveyron, in southern France, caught a boy in the woods. He was about twelve. He’d been seen alone for some years, naked, eating roots. A physician named Jean Itard took him in and worked with him for five years. The boy, called Victor, learned to recognize some written words, to set a table, to respond to his name. He never learned to speak.
Idan: An abused child. An unusual case.
Alan: Unusual because it was recorded. Nobody has gone back to the experiment, because nobody would. But it’s your ranch with the neighbors taken out of the childhood too. Language is the first framework, and it arrives with its slots already shaped. We hear it, we answer in it, and by the time we’re old enough to say “I own myself,” the sentence is borrowed. Idan, you’re quoting Rothbard in English.
Idan: I can own what I’ve inherited. Inheritance isn’t compulsion.
Alan: Agreed. Nobody was compelled to teach you grammar. But you needed it to ask what compulsion is. A man alone on six hundred acres is somebody who already has everything he’d need to be a person, because it was put in him before the gate was locked.
Idan: So the cost is behind me. A debt paid on arrival.
Alan: Paine wrote in Common Sense that “the strength of one man is so unequal to his wants, and his mind so unfitted for perpetual solitude, that he is soon obliged to seek assistance and relief of another, who in his turn requires the same.” That sentence is from 1776. Notice it speaks of the mind first and the strength second.
Idan: Same Paine says “society in every state is a blessing, but government even in its best state is but a necessary evil.” Society, yes. Government, no. That’s my position exactly.
Alan: It’s mine too, if government means the thing that taxes and arrests. In Rights of Man he goes further. “A great part of that order which reigns among mankind is not the effect of government. It had its origin in the principles of society and the natural constitution of man. It existed prior to government, and would exist if the formality of government was abolished.” Society has an order of its own. That order has structure, rules and expected behavior, and it’s what I mean when I say framework.
Idan: You mean norms. Habits.
Alan: Norms, habits, brands, hours, weights, grades, a way to settle who gets the water. A framework is anything that tells two strangers what to expect of each other before they’ve said a word.
Brands and meadows
Idan: Give me an example that isn’t a metaphor.
Alan: Open range. In the cattle country of the West, after the Civil War, thousands of animals grazed ground nobody had fenced. Cattle drifted, mixed, calved in the wrong place. Ranchers fixed it by forming associations, registering brands, keeping brand books, and running a roundup together in spring so each owner could cut out his own. Ownership of a cow, which you think of as natural, was a record in a book that a group of men agreed to honor. Nothing on the animal said whose it was but a mark on its hide and a clerk’s entry.
Idan: And when it worked, the state wasn’t involved.
Alan: Sometimes it wasn’t. I’d call that the point. The people on the range built a framework because no one of them could run cattle without one.
Idan: Fine. Then give me the other half. When the associations got big they shut out small ranchers. The brand book became a weapon.
Alan: It did. Frameworks capture. I’ll give you that without a fight, because everything I’ve written for this collection says it. A framework calls you, and a framework that has stopped being questioned calls you whatever you think of the call.
Idan: Then why would anybody pick one over the gate and the guard dog?
Alan: Because the options aren’t framework or none. In the Swiss village of Törbel, Elinor Ostrom found, farmers have held their high meadows in common for centuries and the cows each household may send up are limited by written rule, recorded since at least 1483. The same families own their fields and orchards outright. Private where private works, common where it doesn’t, and the rule about which is which was kept by people who had to live beside each other for five hundred years.
Idan: Switzerland. A mountain culture, tiny, tight. It doesn’t scale.
Alan: It doesn’t have to. A person lives in a few of these, a family, a parish, a trade, a club, a valley. If one captures him he leaves it, if it’s a good one it stays small enough for him to leave. That’s what separates a framework from a cage. A cage has one door and somebody else holds the key.
Idan: You’ve just described my ranch. Plenty of doors, I hold them all.
Alan: You hold the front gate. You don’t hold the mill, the road or the price of diesel.
What a person is for
Idan: Let me say what’s wrong with the question. “What are people for?” Knives are for cutting. A person is for nothing. That’s the dignity of it. The moment you say a man is for a purpose, somebody else has the purpose in their pocket, and the next thing is a ministry.
Alan: I’d drop “for” if I could. I’d keep what’s behind it. Take away the ministry and the question stays, because it’s yours: you went to a gate on a county road and you wanted six hundred acres. What would you do on them?
Idan: Work. Read. Fix the fence.
Alan: Read what?
Idan: Whatever I’d bring.
Alan: Somebody wrote it. In a language somebody else shaped, after somebody argued against it and somebody else printed it. Reading is the oldest conversation we have with strangers. A man who goes to the ranch to be alone arrives with a library, and his solitude is a long letter back to everyone he’s left. I’m not saying solitude is bad. I think it’s among the best things a person gets. I’m saying it is a thing people do, in company’s absence and not out of it, and that it’s different to be left alone by neighbors than to be without any.
Idan: You think I’d go mad.
Alan: I think you’d put up a mailbox before you put up a barn.
Idan: All right. Say I do. Say I want the mailbox, the mill, the library. I can pay for those. The price system hands me everything you’ve named. Where’s your social framework in that? It’s a market.
Alan: A market is the framework. Prices exist because there’s a way to settle disputes about them, a measure of weight, a record of ownership, a convention that a promise made in Fresno binds a man in Reno. Take any of those out and you don’t have a market that’s freer, you have a market where every sale is a negotiation about whether it happened. People who defend the market and attack the frame are defending an arch and attacking its keystone.
Idan: The keystone doesn’t have to be a government. I’ll take insurers, arbiters, private courts. Rothbard’s whole program.
Alan: And those are institutions, built by people together, with members, rules and a way of replacing the officers. They’re the thing I’m asking for. What you call a refusal of society is a different shape of one.
Idan: Voluntary.
Alan: Most of what I’m describing is. You and I could agree that a framework nobody can leave is a different animal, and still disagree on how many that is.
What the machine does to the ranch
Idan: Here’s where you lose it. Forty years ago my rancher needed a vet, an accountant, a bank teller, a mechanic, a county agent. Today he has a satellite link, a drone over the pasture, solar on the barn roof, and a model that reads the lab result and the tax code. Each year, fewer neighbors. Modernization doesn’t deepen your framework, it dissolves it.
Alan: It dissolves the neighbors. I’d say that’s different.
Idan: Explain.
Alan: What he used to need from people near him, answers, labor, a second pair of hands, he can now get from a screen, and that need has gone down. I’d grant you all of it. But look at what the screen runs on. The link goes up to a satellite someone launched. The chip in the drone comes, for the finest ones, from a handful of fabrication plants, mostly one island. The model was trained on what millions of strangers wrote, argued over and corrected. It’s the largest borrowed vocabulary ever put in a pocket. His distance from the neighbor grew, and his dependence on strangers grew with it, in a form he can’t see.
Idan: Dependence on a market, not on a society.
Alan: On a long chain with no face on it. That’s the cost. Back when he needed the vet he knew the vet, and the vet knew his dog. If the vet cheated him, there was a church, a feed store, a talk at the gate. Now the answer arrives with no one standing behind it. So a second kind of need goes up: someone who can be held to an answer. Who checks the model, who is wronged if it’s wrong, who stops a seller from cutting a corner in a country he’ll never visit. Those are what a society provides when things are small, trust and recourse and a name attached, and they get scarcer as the work gets easier.
Idan: A machine can check a machine.
Alan: And then somebody has to say who checks that one. Each layer of automation moves the question one level up, to the level where somebody decides what counts as correct, and that’s a rule, and a rule needs people who agree to it.
Idan: You’re saying the need falls and rises both.
Alan: The need for hands, for knowledge, for skill, falls. That’s real, and it’s why your ranch is more livable now than at any time since the homestead. The need for standing, to be someone whose word counts and whose complaint reaches somewhere, rises. And one more rises that I’d put quietly: a person who gets every answer from a screen has less occasion to be asked a question. Being asked is how most of us learned what we know. It’s the one thing the machine doesn’t supply, unless the person goes out to find it.
Idan: Then go out and find it. Voluntary.
Alan: Voluntary, and easier to skip every year. I think that’s where this ends up: the old need was forced on us by distance and difficulty, and the new one is a choice with nothing forcing it. Frameworks that used to run on necessity will have to run on being worth joining.
The convention hall
Idan: Then what do you make of the American Liberty Party, since you started on it.
Alan: The plan on its site says it in one line: “Take control of, repurpose, rebrand, and rename the Libertarian Party.” A takeover. Michael Heise, who founded the Mises Caucus, and Bret Weinstein, who joined it in November, want it done at a convention in El Paso in 2028.
Idan: Because the Libertarian Party is empty.
Alan: That’s the claim. Which means they want a hall, a delegate list, bylaws, ballot lines won state by state in parking lots, and a nominee who’ll agree to run. Every item on that list is a framework, and the whole plan depends on a few hundred people agreeing to use it. A movement of individualists, seeking to be taken over by individualists, in order to run a candidate who’ll say the state should leave everybody alone.
Idan: Tool. I said.
Alan: It’s a good one. It was built by thousands of people who believed something specific about government and gathered signatures for it for fifty years. The new party doesn’t want to build what they built. It wants to inherit it, the way you inherited English.
Idan: (a pause, looking at the cattle guard) That’s not a flattering parallel.
Alan: It isn’t meant to flatter. It’s the same one that holds for the rancher. Nobody builds the road or the mill or the vocabulary from nothing. Somebody leaves them, and the question for a person is what to do with an inheritance, which is the nearest thing to an answer I have for what people are for.
Idan: And mine is the gate.
Alan: Yours is a very good gate. It’s the sort a person ought to have, and I’d defend it. I’d only add that it’s hinged on a post somebody else set.
Sources
- Thomas Paine, Common Sense (1776), on society and government and on the strength of one man and the mind “unfitted for perpetual solitude”
- Thomas Paine, Rights of Man, Part Two (1792), on the order that “existed prior to government”
- Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (1949), chapter VIII, “Human Society”
- Murray N. Rothbard, The Ethics of Liberty (1982), on self-ownership
- Jean Marc Gaspard Itard, De l’éducation d’un homme sauvage (1801) and Rapport sur les nouveaux développements de Victor de l’Aveyron (1807)
- Elinor Ostrom, Governing the Commons (1990), chapter 3, on Törbel and the Swiss alpine meadows
- American Liberty Party, So What’s the Plan?
- Independent Political Report, Mises Caucus Launches American Liberty Party, Seeks to Draft Thomas Massie for President (October 27, 2026)
A note on how this piece was written: the conversation is constructed. The positions, the order of the argument and the choice of examples are ours. The sentences were drafted with AI assistance from that direction, with quotations to be checked against their sources, and then edited by hand. We’d rather say that plainly than have a reader guess at it.