Social LibertySocial Liberty

Palo Alto's Problem With Dogs

Palo Alto requires every dog to be leashed in its parks except inside four small fenced areas, together about an acre and a half. A city that has talked about more since 2016 shows how a diffuse public gets what it wants only one hearing at a time.

Margaret Johannsen ·

Click to enlarge

Under the city’s rules, a dog in a Palo Alto park or preserve must be on a leash at all times. The exceptions are the designated dog areas, which the city lists on its own page: Mitchell Park, 0.56 acres. Peers Park, 0.84. Hoover Park, 0.14. Greer Park, 0.06.

Add them up and the dogs of Palo Alto have about 1.6 acres of legal running room, in a city with a good deal more park than that. A dog may run in one of the four enclosures, and only if it is licensed, vaccinated, and wearing its tag. Outside the fence it walks beside someone holding a strap.

Greer’s enclosure is six hundredths of an acre. A dog doing a good sprint crosses it in a few seconds.

What the city has said

Nobody at city hall has argued that dogs shouldn’t run. The Parks and Recreation Commission wrote off-leash space into its 2017 master plan. In 2016 it endorsed new areas at Eleanor Pardee and Bowden parks, and the council, which makes the final call, divided over them. A site at El Camino Park stalled over its nearness to a protected species. Peers Park opened its enclosure in 2018. A local paper ran a headline in 2023 that gave the arithmetic of the wait: promised dog parks, six years and counting.

The city’s page today lists two more on the way: an expansion of Mitchell Park to a little over three-quarters of an acre, with a small-dog section, and a half-acre space as part of renovating Boulware Park. The page gives no date for Boulware.

The shape of the delay

Each proposal went through the same sequence. A site is named. The neighbors of that site learn of it, and some of them object: noise at the fence, the smell, a lawn they had thought was theirs. A staff report weighs the objections. The commission votes, then the council votes, and in between a species or a drainage ditch or a budget line turns up.

The people who want the dog park are many and scattered across the city, and each has a small stake. The people who object live next to the site and have a large stake. A hearing is held at one site on one evening, and it’s the neighbors who come.

Dog owners are not a weak group. They can fill a chamber. Even so, the structure hands the advantage to whoever has the most to lose from a change on a single block, and gives the larger number a much weaker hold on each decision, because each decision looks local.

Can a city regulate how a person walks a dog?

It can, and nobody serious disputes it. In 1897 the Supreme Court, in Sentell v. New Orleans and Carrollton Railroad, treated dogs as a lesser kind of property, subject to the police power in a way a house or a field is not. A leash ordinance passes any court’s test with ease, since a court asks only whether the rule bears some reasonable relation to public safety. The law was settled long before Palo Alto wrote its own.

The harder question is the one the founding generation asked: what is a rule for? Blackstone defined civil liberty as natural liberty restrained by human laws “as is necessary and expedient for the general advantage of the public.” Locke, earlier still, put it more plainly: the end of law is not to abolish or restrain freedom but to preserve and enlarge it. Both let the legislature draw lines around behavior. Both attach a condition. The line has to be bought with a public advantage, and the advantage has to be there.

The Ninth Amendment leaves a small hint of the same temper. The rights listed are not the whole of them, it says, and the people keep others that no list names. A right to run a dog unleashed through a city park is not one a court would take up. The amendment speaks to the ordinary assumption beneath the pleading, that a person who is harming no one is left to go about the day.

Two distinctions keep the argument straight.

The first is between harm and risk. A dog that bites, or fouls a field, or chases a deer, has harmed someone, and the law may answer it after the fact. A dog that might, on some other afternoon, do any of these is a risk, and a rule against risk covers every dog and every owner, the careful and the careless alike. A blanket leash rule is a rule of the second kind. It treats the well-trained dog on the empty field at dusk as the same case as the one that bites.

The second is between a person’s own ground and public ground. A city that tells a homeowner how to walk a dog on a private lawn is regulating conduct. A city that sets terms for a park it owns is also a landlord setting rules for a tenant, which carries more latitude. Palo Alto stands on the stronger side of that line. It still stands there as the owner who has promised, since 2016, to set aside more ground and has not.

So the leash law is lawful, and the spirit of the thing is a separate matter. In the constitutional spirit a restraint is narrow, tied to a harm the public has actually suffered, and paired with a place where the restrained activity is permitted. The first condition is met loosely, the second is skipped, and the third is met in about an acre and a half.

When the rule splits a town

A leash rule is cheap for people who don’t walk dogs. It costs them nothing, and it buys the comfort of a path with no dog on it. It is expensive for the people who do, and it is paid for every day, at the same hour, in the same field.

Minnetonka, Minnesota, shows what follows. The city passed rules that require a leash almost everywhere, with exceptions only in designated places, and then turned to the question of where those places should be. Purgatory Park, where some owners had run their dogs unleashed daily, became the argument. Some residents complained about dogs out of control. Owners objected to losing the freedom they had used for years. A city staff member, Matt Kumka, told reporters, “We’re really truly divided as a community.”

Nothing in the reporting says whether the people who voted for the rule owned dogs, and a rule like this needs no such motive to cause the trouble. It is enough that the people who gain from it and the people who pay for it are different people, who meet at the park gate. Each side then arrives at the next hearing with a grievance it did not have the week before.

Palo Alto’s own history has a smaller version. When the city planned its newest dog area, a city committee’s record notes that park neighbors who didn’t want a dog park near their homes were among the few who took part in the planning. The plan went forward, and it took years.

The officer at the gate

A rule that most people keep needs few enforcers. A rule that large numbers of ordinary people break, in the course of a normal day, hands the enforcement to someone else’s judgment.

Consider the officer sent to a park on a complaint. The dog is off its leash, the owner is a neighbor of ten years, the field is empty but for the caller, and the rule is plain. The officer can write the ticket, and then has made an enemy of the street and a case for the owner to answer. Or the officer can have a word and move on, and then the rule is enforced by mood. Each time the second thing happens, everyone nearby learns how the rule really works: it applies when someone phones.

That is the quiet cost. A law that is broken by the many and enforced on the few turns into a tool for whoever is willing to call. The caller who dislikes dogs, or a neighbor, or the owner of the dog next door, has been given a way to make a grievance official. It places the police between two parties of a quarrel that the city made, and it asks them to resolve it with a citation.

It also draws on a force that has other work. Time spent on a leash call is time not spent elsewhere, and a department asked to answer every such complaint will answer some and drop the rest, which is selective enforcement by another name. I haven’t found figures on how many leash citations Palo Alto issues in a year, and the essay’s argument doesn’t depend on them. A rule that more people follow in the breach than the observance carries this cost at any size of force.

The people who live by the rule every day, who walk the dog at dusk and know where the empty field is, have already made their own judgment about it. When their judgment and the ordinance part ways, the officer is the one who stands in the gap.

A liberal council and a coercive instrument

The word for what happens to the officer is a hard one, and it should be used with its limits in view. Nothing here compares to chattel slavery, which owned a person outright. The older and narrower sense is the one that applies: a person made the instrument of other people’s preferences, set to act against a neighbor whether or not their own judgment agrees. Call it social slavery, a condition in which the one who enforces is as much used as the one who is enforced against.

The officer at the gate did not choose the leash law, and cannot decline it. A council wrote it, and the officer carries it, wearing the uniform and facing the neighbor. The council that wrote it is not in the field.

The irony is in the council’s reputation. Palo Alto’s politics are generally described as liberal, and a body with that self-image tends to think of itself as the side of tolerance, of live and let live, of personal choice in private matters. The ordinance it keeps in force sends an armed agent of the city to settle whether a neighbor held a strap. Council seats there are nonpartisan, and the dog parks have split members along no clean line (a 2017 report in Palo Alto Online described the topic as straddling the council’s ideological divide), so the label describes the city’s temper and says little about any member’s vote.

Liberal and libertarian parted over this long ago. The liberal reflex reaches for a rule and a budget line to answer each discomfort, and sends the enforcement downstairs. What the libertarian wants is the rule that doesn’t need a person to enforce it against a neighbor: a place to run the dog, a fence, and an agreement among the people who use it. The spirit of social liberty asks the council the same thing every time, which is whether it has built the alternative before it asked someone to police the absence.

The hearing as the penalty

In Palo Alto, animal control belongs to the Police Department. It serves Los Altos and Los Altos Hills as well, and the city’s own page says its officers respond to leash complaints. A leash rule there is enforced by the same agency that handles burglaries, under the same badge.

That placement shapes what a dispute feels like. In many California cities an owner who contests an animal-control finding is heard by an officer the chief of police appoints, and appeals to the chief. Tulare’s ordinance is one example of the pattern. I haven’t found Palo Alto’s own procedure, and I can’t say how it treats a leash complaint.

Whatever the exact steps, a pattern worth naming follows from a rule that nearly everyone breaks. The fine for an off-leash dog is small. The cost of contesting it is the afternoon taken off work, the walk into a building with a police seal on it, the formal setting, the official on the other side of the table who answers to the chief. A person who has never been in such a room learns the dog’s walk is a matter for the police.

At that point the process works as the punishment. Few people appeal a fine of that size, because the effort outweighs the sum, and the rule keeps its compliance without ever having to prove its case. A citizen can be frightened by the apparatus whether or not anyone intends it. Whether any particular hearing is meant to frighten is a separate question from whether the arrangement does.

An old principle pulls the other way. The measure of a free society’s laws is whether the person they reach can understand them, answer them in plain view, and meet an adjudicator who owes nothing to the agency that brought the charge. A neighbor’s off-leash dog does not call for a hearing in front of a police chief. It calls for a conversation among the people who share the field.

“We were forced into it”

Ask anyone inside the city’s apparatus why the dog areas are small and few, and the answer comes in one form: we didn’t want it this way. The species at El Camino Park. The neighbors, who must be heard. The environmental review. The budget the council set last spring. The liability exposure, which the city states on its own dog-park page in a single line: the city assumes no liability, and users go at their own risk.

Each of these is real, and each is offered the same way, as a force from outside that the city only passes along. Nobody in the chain decided. A state law required the review, the review turned up the bird, the bird closed the site, and the site was the only one the commission had.

An order with this shape has no author. The officer at the gate carries out a rule the council inherited from a rule the state set, and when a neighbor asks who chose it, the reply is that no one did. It was necessary. A city can then be gentle in its tone and its self-regard, wanting the dog park and wanting the walk to be easy, and still deliver year after year a rule that nobody wanted to be responsible for.

The excuse is partly true, which is its strength. Only the people who stand to gain from fixing it can tell it from the rest, and they are the dog owners at the fence, who have no part in the process that produced it.

We Asked for a Park traced the same structure in San Francisco, where each promise stood on several agencies and no one of them owned the outcome. Responsibility spread across enough offices ends up owned by none, and a government that can’t be held to a result can’t be asked for one either.

A majority, or a way of counting

Do the owners get a say? They get a turn at the podium, three minutes of it, once the neighbors have spoken. Whether that is the voice of a minority being outvoted is a question with more than one answer.

Start with the premise. Dog owners are not a small minority nationally. The American Veterinary Medical Association’s 2024 survey puts dog ownership at about 45.5 percent of households, up from 31.6 percent in 1996. I have no figure for Palo Alto, where the share could run higher or lower, but the national number matters here. If dog households are near half, then the people who want the leash rule enforced and the dog areas kept small are at most a bare majority, and in a city with many owners they may not be a majority at all.

A bare majority, or none, still produces a council that votes as though a large one stood behind it. The way the city counts does some of that work.

Palo Alto elects its seven council members at large, in November of even-numbered years, to staggered four-year terms. In a district system, a bloc that was 45 percent of the city could carry the districts where its members live. At large, the whole city votes on every seat, and a bloc spread evenly across the map can be outvoted in all of them. Turnout adds its own tilt. About 36 percent of Palo Alto’s registered voters turned out in 2014, which means a council is chosen by a minority of the city. The ones most likely to be in that minority are the ones with the time, the homes, and the long tenure that a hearing about a park also rewards.

None of this makes the council’s vote a fraud. It makes it a measurement of one thing, which is who shows up and organizes, and it is read afterward as a measurement of another, which is what the city wants.

Madison saw the shape of this in Federalist No. 10: a majority faction, bound by a common interest adverse to the rights of other citizens or to the permanent interests of the community, can act on the rest without check. Mill, in On Liberty, added the part that applies on a street corner. The danger is less the law than the opinion behind it, a settled preference of the many that the few feel as pressure in daily life, in what the neighbors expect to see on a walk.

Both thought the answer was structural: a share of the decision that does not turn on the count of the day. In dog-park terms, that is a field the owners govern themselves, as the people with the most at stake in it. A vote on whether other people may keep a dog on the grass does not do that.

Whose trouble is it

Follow the incentive one step further. A private business that makes a problem for its customers loses them. A department that makes a problem for the public gets a bigger case for its budget. A rule that nobody can fully enforce, a dispute that needs a hearing, an animal-control office that needs officers to answer the calls: each is a task, and a task is a position, and a position has a salary. Solved, the dog problem would shrink the work. Unsolved, it is steady.

I don’t mean that anyone at the department wants the dog areas kept small. The point is narrower, and it needs no bad motive. An organization whose income depends on the size of the problem it is assigned will be less eager than its neighbors to see the problem go away, and the people who decide its budget are asked to take its word on how big the problem is.

Franklin Roosevelt saw a version of this in 1937, writing to the head of a federal employees’ union. Collective bargaining, he said, as usually understood, could not be transplanted into the public service, because in the public service the employer is the whole people, and officials sit on both sides of the table. A union can bargain with a private owner. It bargains here with officials the voters chose, and sometimes with some that the union’s own members helped elect.

How much that happens in Palo Alto is a matter of record, and the record shows less than the phrase “a government made of the union” suggests. In the 2018 council race, reporting listed labor contributions to one candidate in the hundreds and low thousands of dollars: the city’s firefighters’ union gave $1,000, and SEIU Local 521, which represents about half the city’s employees, gave $250. Reporting on that city’s council races in the same years was far more concerned with developers and real-estate money. I haven’t found the police officers’ association’s giving to council candidates, and the question of how much leverage it has has no answer in those figures.

What the figures can’t show is the quieter influence. A council that depends on the department for the facts, the options and the estimates has a relation with it already, and no check needs to be written for it to exist. The officer enforces the leash rule. The department tells the council what the enforcement costs and how the public responds, and the council decides based on the report.

Who lives under the rule

Palo Alto’s council appoints a city manager, and the manager runs the departments. On paper the elected members hold the power: they set the budget, they hire the manager, they can let the manager go. The residents choose the council, and the council chooses the rest.

A fact about the staff sits oddly with that picture. A few years ago the city’s assistant city manager told a television station that only about 10 percent of Palo Alto’s employees, or a little less, live in the city. The report doesn’t carry a date I can confirm, so the share may have moved since.

The reasons are not hard to find, and they do not reflect on the people. A city with Palo Alto’s housing prices prices out most of the officers, clerks and planners it employs. The same report described the council voting unanimously to raise pay for nearly 600 employees in four unions to help more staff live nearer work, and a fire department official said no one could live within ten or twenty miles of the city on the old scale. The city is not at fault for its rents in any simple way, and no single cause accounts for them.

The consequence for the dogs is plain. Those who write the reports, answer the complaints, enforce the rule and advise the council on what it should do mostly go home somewhere else. They don’t walk a dog at dusk on Greer’s patch of grass, they don’t live next to a proposed fence, and they don’t stand in line at a hearing as a neighbor. The rule is made for people they know through a counter or a case file.

That doesn’t reduce the council’s power in law. In practice a council of part-time officials, serving a few terms, depends on a full-time staff for the options, the cost estimates and the account of what the law allows. The members vote, and the staff decide what is put to the vote. The residents who elected the council are two steps from the decision, and the people closest to it have no particular stake in how a walk feels.

A resident could take that as a grievance against the staff. It reads better as an account of what happens to a town when its own people no longer work for it: the work is done by a body that serves it from a distance, and what the town has left is a vote on the budget.

What the council may still decide

A fair question to put to every section above is whether the council could fix the dog areas if it wished to. In land, the answer has been narrowing for years.

California’s housing law has moved a growing share of land decisions out of city hall. The Housing Accountability Act, from 1982 and tightened since, limits a city’s grounds for turning down a housing project that meets its published standards. SB 35, from 2017, made approval of qualifying projects ministerial, a word that means staff check the boxes and no one gets to weigh in. SB 9, from 2021, lets an owner of a single-family lot build more than one home on it or split the lot, with the same absence of discretion. The state also assigns each city a number of homes it must plan for, and a city that fails to adopt a plan the state accepts can have projects approved that its own zoning would bar.

Whatever one makes of these laws, and a case can be made that they open the way to more homes and more neighbors, they change what a council is. Over the land inside the city’s borders, a council elected by the residents may not be the one that decides, and a neighbor who comes to a hearing to ask for a say learns that the hearing has no say to give.

The restrictions reach staff as well. A planner or a parks manager who wants to answer what the public asks for works within a mesh of review requirements, state deadlines, mandated findings and exposure to suit. Each was written to guard against something, and the whole of it makes a quick answer to a plain request very hard to give. A dog area is a small thing, and the same mesh catches it, as it did at El Camino Park, where the nearness of a protected species stalled the site.

This is the larger answer to the first question. The city did not choose all of its constraints, and some of the forces it cites are real. The pattern runs both ways, upward to the state and downward to the neighbors, and it leaves the resident who wants a place to run a dog facing a set of officials who each point somewhere else. Paine, in Common Sense in 1776, objected to a continent governed by an island, a government at a distance that decided for people without hearing from them. The distance has since moved up from London to Sacramento, and also in from the capital to the neighbor next door, and the person in between still has no one to ask.

Where the leash law comes from

A leash requirement is a reasonable answer to a real problem: dogs and children and joggers and wildlife share the same grass. It is also a rule written for the case where nothing better exists. The better arrangement would be a place to run a dog where it harms no one, and that arrangement is the one the city has promised and not yet built.

So the rule does more than it says. It turns each walk into a small act of compliance, and it turns the owner who lets a dog loose at dusk on an empty field into an offender, in a city that agrees the dog should have somewhere to go.

We Asked for a Park followed a San Francisco square from request to restroom (read it here), and it found that behind each promise a government makes stand several agencies, and no one of them owns the result. Palo Alto’s dogs are a smaller instance. No one is against the dog park in general. Each is stopped in particular.

A question the arrangement can’t ask

Suppose the parcel at issue belonged to a body that could answer for it: a neighborhood association, a land trust, a park conservancy with a fenced field and a membership list. The neighbors who object would deal with a group that lives where they live, and the group would hear them, adjust the hours and the fence line, and carry on. A dog park would then be an ordinary thing to build, one the neighborhood decided on.

A city with a council and a commission can do this too, in principle. In practice a decision made so far from the fence is made on paper, and the paper takes six years.


Sources

  • City of Palo Alto, Dog Parks (paloalto.gov/dogparks): site acreages, rules, and planned expansions
  • City of Palo Alto, Dogs in Open Space Preserves (leash requirement in parks and preserves)
  • Palo Alto Online, coverage of dog parks, 2016 to 2023, including “Promised dog parks, 6 years and counting” (2023)
  • Sentell v. New Orleans & Carrollton Railroad Co., 166 U.S. 698 (1897)
  • William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England, Book I, ch. 1 (civil liberty)
  • John Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1689), section 57
  • U.S. Constitution, Ninth Amendment
  • CBS Minnesota, “Minnetonka residents divided over new leash rules, dog owners call for more freedom”
  • City of Palo Alto, Parks and Recreation Commission and committee documents on dog-park planning (neighbor participation)
  • City of Palo Alto, Animal Control Division (paloalto.gov/animalcontrol): run by the Police Department
  • City of Tulare municipal code on animal-control appeals to the Chief of Police, as an example of the pattern
  • American Veterinary Medical Association, 2024 U.S. pet ownership survey (about 45.5 percent of households own a dog)
  • City of Palo Alto, City Clerk, City Council Elections (at-large, staggered terms); Palo Alto Online election coverage, 2014 (turnout about 36 percent)
  • James Madison, Federalist No. 10 (1787); John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859), chapter 1
  • Franklin D. Roosevelt, letter to Luther C. Steward, president of the National Federation of Federal Employees (August 16, 1937), on collective bargaining in the public service
  • Palo Alto Online, council-race campaign finance coverage, 2016 and 2018 (labor and developer contributions)
  • KPIX 5 / CBS News, “Palo Alto Police, Firefighters Get Raises To Deal With High Housing Prices” (assistant city manager on the share of employees living in the city; undated)
  • California Government Code on the Housing Accountability Act (1982), SB 35 (2017) and SB 9 (2021)
  • Margaret Johannsen, We Asked for a Park

A note on how this piece was written: the topic and direction are mine. The sentences were drafted with AI assistance from that direction, with the 2016 to 2023 council history, the current park acreages, and the legal citations, the council-manager form, the California housing statutes as summarized, the employee-residency figure, the Roosevelt letter, and the quotations still to be checked against the city’s records, Palo Alto Online and the sources, and then edited by hand. I’d rather say that plainly than have a reader guess at it.

Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X