Social LibertySocial Liberty

Michael Heise on the American Liberty Party

On a Mises Caucus podcast on November 18, Michael Heise answered Dave Smith and Scott Horton on whether Massie should stay in the Republican primary, whether a party can be renamed in every state, and what $50 million buys a guerrilla campaign.

Social Liberty Foundation ·

Click to enlarge

Watch the full conversation on YouTube

Michael Heise, who founded the Libertarian Party’s Mises Caucus, spoke with Nate Thurston on episode 176 of Decentralized Revolution, the Mises Caucus podcast, streamed live on November 18, 2026. It ran about an hour and twenty-three minutes. What follows is a transcript from the YouTube captions: filler words, false starts and a few moments of chat housekeeping are trimmed, caption errors are corrected from context, and speaker turns are assigned by reading, so a turn may sit on the wrong side of a line. Chapter headings are the video’s own. Remarks about other people are Heise’s or Thurston’s, not ours. For our reading of the plan, see Rebranding a Borrowed Line; for what stood out in this conversation, see What a Party Is For.

Nate: What’s up everyone? Welcome to episode 176 of Decentralized Revolution, the Mises Caucus podcast. My name is Nate Thurston. Our co-host Aaron Harris. Could not be here tonight. Really sorry about that.

But we got a good one. I am joined by the one and only Michael Heise, who’s the founder of the Libertarian Party Mises Caucus. He’s the guy who is leading the charge to take over the party rebranded as the American Liberty Party, and my favorite draft, Thomas Massie for president.

So, what’s up, Michael? How’s it going?

Heise: I’m good, Nate. Good to be here. It’s been a while.

Nate: It has been a long time. I was trying to figure out exactly what year it was that we talked. You came to our studio in Nashville for Good Morning Liberty. I think with Josiah, and did an interview in our studio here in Nashville. So, that’s been years now, many years now. It’s the first time we’ve talked since then, you’re working on something right now.

You’re a pretty busy guy, I’m sure. And a lot of people know what that thing is. I want to give everyone a little bit of an outline of some of the stuff I want to talk about tonight, which is I want to cover why you feel it’s important to do this, how difficult or easy it’s going to be to actually do like all the mechanics.

And then I definitely want to cover some of the comments that I heard made recently by some of the big people on our side like Dave Smith and Scott Horton, and then I definitely want to cover some of Scott’s comments.

I want to make sure that this is actually something that is legally possible to do. So that was one of the biggest closings of that episode was all the stuff he said there. So, first off, all that said, tell me about the idea and the vision behind the American Liberty Party.

The case for a new party

Heise: So, it’s funny, me and Bret have been talking about something like this for a long time. Like, Bret has been interested in these kind of third party projects for a long time, trying to find viable avenues to do that, and the whole project wouldn’t have been possible if it wasn’t for Tucker Carlson, like Tucker Carlson kind of ignited the conversation about we need a new party and kind of hinted that he was going to start a new party, obviously Massie was a part of that. Marjorie Taylor Green was a part of that. Joe Kent was a part of that and it ignited this conversation, and a lot of people millions and millions of people got very excited about this idea because of what they’re getting because of the betrayal that happened from Trump.

Obviously, the Democrats aren’t a choice for these kinds of people, and people are just getting screwed left and right. And it’s it’s getting it’s getting to a point where like, yes, we as libertarians know government is force and all of that stuff, but like in polite society where, you know, you have this pretense of the consent of the governed and stuff like that, that’s just going away, if not fully gone at this point.

And people are starting to get very worried. And so Tucker starting that conversation really greased the wheels for me to say, “Hey, you know, if you’re going to start a new party, Bobby Kennedy tried to do this essentially, he didn’t try to start a party, but he tried to get on the ballot in all 50 states from scratch and he spent about $30 million, came up short, ended up in court, you know, all of this stuff.”

And so it’s not really practical. And so it’s like, hey, if you want to start a new party compared to doing it from scratch, there is a Libertarian Party right there that has ballot access in most states, that’s doesn’t have too much going on. It doesn’t have candidates that can galvanize its own base, let alone a base outside of itself, that’s been going on for a while now.

People don’t want to run. It’s had, you know, struggles just catching ground.

And so it’s right there. It’s the third most ballot present institution in the country, and that is very tactically important in this dire time that we’re going into. And so maybe now is the time to try to turn it into something to we have this kind of middle road where you have a new party, but you also have ballot access and you can pretty quickly start to get to operations, and so with that idea and with the creasing of the wheels, frankly, of Tucker igniting that conversation, I was able to have a lot of conversations with a lot of people very quick, and got a lot of support. And so, you know, at the end of that process of those conversations, here we are with Bret Weinstein going public as the first guy through the door. And the reception’s been awesome.

Nate: So obviously I think there’s a lot of parts of that coalition that got Trump elected that are very upset right now. Many of them probably never consider voting Republican again. They might not consider themselves libertarians or they might not want to stick that word libertarian next to their name because of what that party represents sometimes or you know in the public sphere anyway. So, I guess my big one big question I have is like what’s the problem with the Libertarian Party? Why not just use them? Why not bring these people into the Libertarian Party and let them be the alternative to the Republican party?

Issues with the LP brand

Heise: I mean, that’s what we’d all like to see, right? And let’s first be clear about what this coalition is because you had mentioned before and I think it’s an important fact that this coalition of people already exists. It already is together. It’s already voting together.

And what brought them together originally? What brought them together originally was Trump in 24 when he created the coalition. He created the coalition when he brought RFK and Tulsi and Elon and you know there was outreaches to Ron Paul and talking about Massie being agriculture secretary like all of this stuff this motley crew of people that were brought together that I mean it’s why I voted for Trump not so much for Trump but to say holy [expletive] this looks like legitimately different that’s a really weird right-wing this might really be a dissident thing you know let’s take a swing on it and so the issues that brought these people together are things like corruption, waste and spending and fraud, getting the spending under control, no new wars, all of that kind of stuff that is red meat for libertarians to begin with.

And so it’s already a big win for our issues. And so why not just do the regular libertarian party thing? Because if these people wanted to be libertarians, you know, in the big L sense, they would have already been doing it.

And not only that, but as I said, the Tucker Carlson starting that conversation has enabled me to have a lot of conversations with people with large audiences from very different sectors of this coalition. And everybody but people who are inside of the party can see that the brand of the Libertarian Party is tainted. You know, like one of the biggest news stories of this election cycle, whether anybody likes it or not, is a guy who put a suicide letter up on a candidate, no less, who put a suicide letter up on Facebook and then goes on a police chase reaching out to media while he’s doing it.

Like just crazy stuff. And that’s what we’re known for. We’re known for the boot on the head. We’re known for the, you know, the guy dancing naked and all this stuff.

And so, this coalition already exists, but I think we have to do something ourselves with our own party to kind of signal to them that we’re ready to leave that baggage behind. And on top of that, part of this whole thing for me is I’m going to have to start saying some truths that are just uncomfortable and might get me booed.

And here’s one of them. Libertarians at large don’t care about the party, this wouldn’t be necessary if that was not the case. But they’re not willing to maintain the party. They’re not willing to upkeep the party. They’re not willing to keep it out of the hands of leftists, you know, and all of that things that horribly misrepresent libertarians.

And so we have to try something different.

Nate: Yeah. I’ve I’ve been saying for a while now before any of this came up and I don’t know if you’ll agree with me but I think the Libertarian Party’s had an issue that it’s got the word libertarian in its name and that represents I don’t know what you call it a philosophy, a political philosophy or an ideology or something, and it gives everyone something to argue over and purity test over and what the real libertarian actually is and the model libertarian actually is and that’s something that the other parties don’t have to deal with.

I think it’s good to have a simple set of principles, but there’s so much infighting and I really think it comes from having a party that’s also supposed to represent an entire ideology – and I don’t think that those things are cohesive at all. I don’t think they go together and I think we’ve seen that.

Heise: Yeah, it forces you to go into every like rigid edge of that philosophy and now you have to whether it’s within political reality or not and that’s what politics is the art of the real right like what you can actually do, and I think it also comes from a different time and I think people are not really caught up to this reality.

A shifting political landscape

Heise: This is another one of those unpopular truths and this is something that I me personally used to not say what I’m about to say, when the party was originally founded, think about it. It’s 1972, you know what I mean? And for a very, very long time, we had a situation where the narrative, the ideas, and the conversation was completely gatekept by the media. And that persisted for a very long time. I mean, all the way up to at least 2012.

I would argue it started to break in 2016. And I don’t think it was until really this election that it fully broke. I mean, what was kind of the big moment where everyone that coalition kind of finally formed behind Trump? I would argue was when he started going on Rogan and Theo Von and accepting this new medium that is a real source of voters, a real source of people, a large audience and all of that. And that was kind of one of the defining end points of the establishment media. Now, they have they still have a important role to play, especially within the primaries.

But the point that I’m making here is that this whole idea of the party being the thing that goes out and says the message, that’s dead. That can’t be done by a political party anymore. That’s done by podcasters and influencers, you know, like this. I’ll hear some people say like, “Oh, well, Ron Paul ran in 2012 and that’s what created the Liberty Movement and all of that.” And look, my middle my son’s middle name is Ron, like I love Ron to death, you know, however, back then it this was still the case.

What I would argue now is like take what’s happened with the whole Israel lobby issue, the Gaza issue. Where’s the candidate that lit that firestorm of conversation that has turned the polling around on Israel in 3 years?

It doesn’t exist. That is an organic process of the brakes being taken off the conversation as the media has died and podcasters did that. Norman Finkelstein did that. Dave Smith did that. You know what I mean? Like all of these guys just going onto these huge audiences have been able to completely change the culture in a way that in times past you might say, “Well, we need somebody to go out in the political arena and get the message out.” That’s done.

But that is not the role of a political party. So the party now has to earn its salt in the political arena in some sense, I would argue, to even justify its existence. I don’t think that’s really talked about.

Nate: One thing I want to make sure we mention and maybe it’ll be better when we’re talking about some of the responses from people, but you just mentioned that some of that stuff was some of these people were important in the midterms or in the primaries, sorry, and that really is the case like there are different people that vote in the primaries and that those people might not be the ones that are getting their political news from Joe Rogan or Theo Von or different podcasts, they might be more Fox News people.

And we do know that a guy like Massie was just saying last week that he did suffer from the Fox News blackout and was not able to get through his primary because so many of the people were just watching Fox News all the time. And I would argue, I’ll probably add this on later, that’s a big thing that people are still going to have to deal with at least for the next 15 or 20 or so years, if you catch what I’m saying, that’s still going to be an issue. It could be the case that eventually all those younger voters that’s not going to be the issue fifteen, twenty years from now, but it is still currently and it will be in the next election and the next few elections for sure.

So, I’m sorry. I don’t know that was a question. I just want to make sure I get that point out there.

Rising but untapped potential of young voters

Heise: No, it’s a big point and we could dig into it if you want, but it’s absolutely true, like the primary voting data is very clear that the brightest run and this is across both parties that the brightest line is age demographic and that the interests of young people generally speaking.

I mean yes you could break it off into left/right libertarian and all of that but generally speaking the interests of young people are not the interests of older people that are voting. And the average age of a primary voter in the GOP is over 60 years old.

And so when you dig into say Massie’s election data, he completely dominated everyone under 55 like hard. And the younger you go, the harder he dominated it. Literally the only age demographic that he lost was 55 and up. And yet that was enough. And they came out in such force because of the media blackout, because of the lobby money that came in that was enough to get people to come out.

And he lost the race by 10 points. And the thing is it’s not just Massie like he’s the crown gem of kind of creat making the point of this in the data but there’s all these other kind of dissident candidates not libertarians they’re not exactly the same as Massie but they’re still very useful data points.

It just came out that James Fishback won like 70s something of 18 to 29 in his governor’s race in Florida. Casey Putsch, he was an America First dissident for governor in Ohio. None of these people won.

Monty Fritts, another one of these people in Tennessee. None of these people won. Monty Fritts, I think, did the best at like 22. Other than that, they all got shut out.

So young people do not have a voice at all. At all. And so that’s a big part of the driving force of this project.

Nate: This allows you to get that person through that primary process in the current party’s style of primary process and on the ballot in the general and so you can actually have that effect at that time and not just in the primary.

Heise: What the data is showing very clearly is that young people who have these divergent interests… if you put them in a pitch battle in a primary against these older voters they lose every time. However, they have there is enough people out there who are independent that for two election cycles in a row in a nonpartisan pattern have swung the election both ways that so they came together in the coalition behind Trump for the issues that we already mentioned and when they got screwed on that they either voted Trump something like I don’t want to say the wrong I think it was 20 or 25% or upwards of 30 maybe you can fact check me but something like 30% of Trump voters either voted Democrat or stayed home.

Nate: 35 is the number that I heard. Jesus Christ. Okay.

Heise: So yeah, so some insane number and that’s very good news because that is general election numbers and this is a huge group of people enough to swing the biggest elections that the country has to give and they’re doing it in a nonpartisan fashion.

And so what I’m saying, these young people that can’t win these primaries, if you just yank them out and put them over into their own lane with their own set of interests being represented, they’re probably still not enough to win because that’s also what the data shows that America First is not enough to win, but it is enough to decide who does win.

And that is a lot of power if you can put that into its own lane. And that’s what we’re trying to do.

Massie and election tactics, going outside the bubble

Nate: So I want to ask you which direction you want to go because there’s things we can cover like the actual mechanics of doing this and maybe that’s important to put at the end – like call to action for people like how do we do this you know go going out in the states and getting this done, because right now we’re really we’re really covering some of the dissenting views I’ve heard so far and I do think it’s important to bring up some of this. I of course correct me if I’m wrong. I just I love Thomas Massie. He’s great. I don’t see him doing I don’t see him winning a Republican primary and going on to become the president.

It’s not something I see happening. My news feed is like 90% pro Thomas Massie. Here’s how great he is. But when I leave that bubble, I see the result that he got in his primary or worse, and so I just don’t see I’m not as optimistic as some of the dissenting voices I’ve heard about the choices that the Republican party are going to make or that they’ve learned their lesson all of a sudden after what just happened in the midterms.

I’ve actually see them going harder after the midterms in their direction, especially when you’re led by someone so narcissistic. It’s more likely that people are going to double down and point the finger and try to shift blame and say, “See, we told you we were right. We should have gone harder on the war or we something like that.”

Then they’re going to learn their lesson and decide that Massie is the one that we should have been listened to. And Massie himself is going to prove this point before he leaves because he intends to for excuse me force a war powers resolution vote before he leaves.

Heise: And if that thing does not pass, I mean, what a slap in the face to the American people. And what more do you have to know that they didn’t learn anything? And not only they didn’t learn anything, they do not give a [expletive] about the young people and all of the people that they’ll sit home. They’re fine with just those boomers coming out and voting, you know? Sorry for any boomers listening. Like not all of them, but it is a statistical trend, but you know and they just don’t care.

They’re totally fine servicing the donors and letting everybody else rot because the political system was going to it already runs on a minority of people, you know, and so they don’t give a [expletive] the other thing that Massie said that is very encouraging to me is what he said on breaking points when he said, “Well, you know, there’s these three paths and I’m just going to do some polling, I think, and kind of decide what’s best.”

And that certainly jives with what he told me personally in private conversations and but I’m already confident of what that data shows because to the extent that you have data on to this point where of how Massie stands in a GOP primary it’s like 1 to 2%. You know and people want to talk about Ron Paul and oh well Ron Paul did this before Ron Paul entered the primary in 2008 he was at about 1 to 2%. So if you want to map it to Ron Paul, this is looking so far within a primary context a lot more 08 than 12.

And so I think but I think the claim from there is yeah well Massie will go out and dominate these debates and and win the people over. But again, if the primary pool is something like JD Vance, Marco Rubio, Ron DeSantis, who else? Chris Christie I think is said he might run Ted Cruz. Mike Pence like it might run like as these people start to come off who is flocking to Massie, you know what I mean?

Nate: Like from that pool of people? What is the average age of a primary voter in the GOP?

Heise: Yeah, it’s over where Massie dominated in his primary. And in his primary, he has very big structural advantages that he does not have if you stretch him across a national election, a national primary like that. He was a seven-term incumbent. He had name saturation. He was popular. It’s not like he eaked out victories these past 12, 14 years or whatever.

He was faking dominating, you know, and so what he attributed it to was the blackout on Boomercon Media. So, Fox, OAN, Newsmax, the lobby money, and the Trump endorsement. And he went as far as to say, if those things are still present, I think I lose again. Those things are still present. And so, and so what the data shows is that there isn’t really a path. And so another one of these unpopular truths that I think I have to say that we need to get our heads around of and start thinking tactically around is that America first in the broadest biggest sense of the word.

Like if you even want to go groypers to libertarians – like the absolute furthest stretch of that term – it’s not enough. It’s not enough of the American electorate to win elections on its own. It’s just not. And there’s no evidence to show that it is. There is enough evidence to show that it can swing elections, but it’s just not there. And whereas one piece of data that does exist for Massie is back in February, Rich Baris, people’s pundit, did an independent poll of Massie in a three-way race, okay? Against I think it was AOC and Newsom, and he polled at 10% in February of this year, again to map that out.

Gary Johnson – not the best analog, but it’s best one we’ve got. It’s the best one we’ve got. Gary Johnson during the campaign hit a peak of 12%. Before he ever got the nomination, he was polling at about 1 to 2%. Ron Paul before him again in ‘08, 1 to 2%.

Now the other thing that’s interesting about the Ron Paul case is because I think the appeal of Massie running in the primary is like, well, because he’s so popular with independence that he can win that race. You know, if he were to somehow get through the primary, then he can win the general and then you’re president and we solve all these problems and, you know, it’s just easy.

You just go pull the lever, and that existed with Ron Paul. Ron Paul was literally the only one in I think it was 2012 who had a Rasmussen poll showing him winning head-to-head against Obama and the GOP didn’t give a [expletive] They chose [Romney], and so I think that is still there. And not to mention just the structure of the GOP like how do you get through the precinct captains? How do you get through the lobby? How do you get through the continued blackout? You know, all of these things.

So, when you’re talking about he’s pulling at 10% right now in a three-way general, that’s probably closer to the floor than the ceiling is what the pattern shows. Yes, people might say, “Oh, well, if then the third party candidate polls better than they do, and that’s true. However, if that’s the closer to the floor and he can hit 15 20%.”

Now, you’re talking debates. Now you’re talking not just minor party status and ballot access. Now you’re talking major party status and it’s a whole new world after that historic like totally historic outcome in third party politics opening up legally speaking a new lane within American politics and so I think that’s amazing. I think Massie has said many times that he does not want to go back to DC. And so I suspect that there is an appeal to Massie personally where he if he can do something like if he can go out and do something that builds something that lasts beyond the election cycle and he also doesn’t go back to DC. I suspect that is appealing to him at the very least too.

Nate: I would say I would hope something he is interested in after being elected Republican for a while is making the party better like competition makes things better and right now they don’t have any actual competition and I think you know I don’t really care about political parties just so you know I never told you this before I don’t care where the positive change comes from don’t care what it’s called I want lots more freedom.

You know, to be kind of tacky right there, cliche that I want less government, more freedom. I don’t care what party it actually comes from. And anything that makes the other parties better is a good thing. And what you were just talking about, he runs in a general, he gets 15 20% something like that. Well, he might not win, but they’ll take that lesson.

Heise: They’re going to look at that and they’re going to say, “Oh, wow, there’s a lot of people out there that are interested in this thing and people might say well that already gonna do that of course that’s already what people are looking at with how these elections just went and I don’t know if that’s the case; I think you run I’m sorry I have to jump in there I don’t think so it’s depending on who they is voters are you know what I mean like I think voters just swung the election because a self-respecting population can’t take this level of betrayal And there’s no other way to voice that discontent than to let the Democrats win.

But what are you watching in the Democrats right now? Hakeem Jeffries is about to be the House majority leader. Yeah. You know, they’re going to put through another establishment thing, another establishment person in the Senate. And so the lobby wins every time.

The house wins every time. And so their dissidents are getting screwed just the way the same as the dissident and the young people on the right. And so that’s where this environment is coming. And so the house always wins, the young people always lose. And there is absolutely will there which is to try something new which is why it went so viral when Tucker started this conversation.

Nate: No, I definitely think that’s right. I just think he runs in the primary doesn’t do well. They don’t really learn the lesson. Eventually the parties just realize that they keep doing what they’ve been doing which is present themselves as better than the other party. Like the whole goal now is to scare the other side. Scare your side about the other side.

And I think that’s right. Like they just have to convince people that the their lives would be worse if the other guys get in office. And the Republicans have decided that they can just be better than Democrats and that means they’ve earned your vote, which is a terrible idea for anyone to go along with. That means they can continue getting worse, as the, you know, Democrats become more and more communist. And as long as the Republicans are socialists instead of communists, then you got to vote for them, it’s it’s a terrible strategy. I just think in the spirit of competition overall, it’s better for everyone that there is legitimate competition here.

Addressing internal criticism

Nate: I’ve got a few quotes that I wrote down here from the episode between Dave Smith and Scott Horton. Do you mind if I read a couple of them?

Heise: Of course. Let’s do it.

Nate: So Dave Smith said, “you just saw this coalition win in the Republican party. Why would we not pursue the path that could win?”

I think we’ve been covering that one already, that he’s a lot more optimistic about it than I am, which is surprising to say after all the things that we’ve gone through over the last couple years, that that’s actually a coalition that’s going to win in the Republican party maybe 15, 20 years from now. I don’t know, let me see here. Ron Paul ran as a libertarian and nobody cared. He ran as a Republican and changed our paths forever. It’s another quote from that episode. Do you want me to I’m sorry. Do you want me to address these as you say them?

Heise: Yes. Go ahead. Anytime. Anytime. So, all right. Let me start with the first one. Can I’m sorry.

Nate: Can you say it again? He said Ron Paul ran is a libertarian. Nobody cared. So, he’s talking party. Talking third party. Oh, the first one was you just saw this coalition win in the Republican party, why would we not pursue the path that could win?

Heise: So what I would say to that Republican party. What I would say to that is we saw them win in 24. We didn’t see them win this year. And it goes to my point that this is a group of people that is not married to a party. They are not married to a personality. They are married to a certain set of interests that they have in common.

And that set of interests is red meat for us as libertarians. It’s free speech. It’s no more wars. It’s get the spending under control, get the waste, fraud, and abuse. It’s immigration. It’s it’s all of these things that they have in common, which is red meat for us to begin with.

Okay? And so we can take charge in delivering a vehicle for these people to have a voice to still, you know, strive towards these things within the political arena, and so that’s what they just showed you. Yeah, they won in 24, but they’re also willing to just say, “We’ll let the Democrats win.” So they’re already there. They’re already voting together and they’re already voting nonpartisanally and so they’re just formless though. They’re formless. They’re without a weapon. They’re without they’re without, you know, anything to kind of more or more organizationally assert themselves. Mhm.

Nate: I got you. I that I don’t know if you want to address the second one either. He’s he was talking third party. Ron Paul ran as a libertarian. Nobody cared. He ran as a Republican and changed all of our paths forever, which is true for me. I don’t know if it’s true for you also.

Heise: No, dude. I’ve talked extensively about like how Ron Paul changed my life and gave me like a role model look over. My son’s middle name is Ron. Like, dude, I love Ron Paul to absolute death, but the world is not the idea that the world is the same as 1988 when he ran as a libertarian or in 1992 when James Buchanan ran as a third party or even 2012 when Ron Paul ran as a Republican. It is just now a different world.

And again, the example there is who is the candidate that went out there and said, you know, we have a serious Israel lobby thing that we have to think about in this country.

There was no candidate because it is a completely different world now that the brakes are taken off of the conversation and the media has been destroyed. We’re in a completely new world of possibility.

There’s also just a lot more pain out there, you know, like I don’t think young people in 1988 were quite at the level of I don’t know what my future looks like as they are right now. You know, I don’t think it’s the same world in any sense of the world, any sense of the word in a post dead media world, and so I think that creates all new kinds of possibilities, one of which we already saw and should be celebrated.

Dave is the one, well, one of the people who killed the lobby, one of the biggest people who is helping to kill the lobby through taking the brakes off of that conversation. And so, it’s a completely different world.

Nate: And I’ll add one thing with the Ron Paul conversation, which don’t nobody take this the wrong way. I love Ron Paul as much as the next guy. He’s the whole reason I’m here right now doing this show or my other show being a libertarian at all, he did run. He got a lot of support – it was really cool. The government has more than doubled in size since then. There was a Tea Party movement. The Republican party rose up and destroyed all of them. It’s cool that he got out there and got a lot of us enthusiastic.

Heise: I agree.

Nate: But no one ever got close to having the power to actually make the government smaller.

Heise: Correct. When we reflect on Ron Paul, nobody is reflecting on Ron Paul to say, well, you know, because of those races, the structure of the GOP is more libertarian now or it’s more peace, you know, peacenik now or it’s more conservative now or it’s more concerned about spending now or concerned about, you know, civil liberty.

Nobody talks about what Ron Paul did in an actually political sense because he didn’t win the race. What he talks about is a cult. What we talk about him is as a cultural sense. Do you remember the world that you lived in 2012?

Like we didn’t nobody knew what the [expletive] the Federal Reserve was. That was the thing like the mind blow like dude what they control the money and like you know all of this stuff. Nobody knew. Every 5-year-old with the phone knows about what the Fed is now. You know what I mean? Like we were all conspiracy theory nerds back then.

You know what I mean? Like and trying to like go against the grain of polite society and all this stuff and again the conversation is just that the brakes are off, you know what I mean? And so we need a we are talking in the like they’re saying, “Oh, well, he can win.” And if you’re talking he being Massie, they’re saying he can win. So if you’re talking about that and then trying to back draw it back to Ron Paul, that’s not what Ron Paul did. And that’s also not what Ron Paul set out to do either.

You know what I mean? He set out to teach us in those dark times.

Nate: Yeah, he did a good job. Great job at it. I got there’s one thing he said which I’ll agree with is like my biggest fear maybe libertarians listening to this won’t like hearing me say this. I’ll say a harsh truth that I wouldn’t normally say on this show: I prefer Republicans to Democrats still, like the Democrats answer to everything is to use the government to run every part of your lives. And at least the Republicans, there’s some of them who try to not do that, and that’s good.

They’re the devil. I know, I guess, and so one of the points that Dave makes is he’s very his quote, “I’m very concerned about the Democratic establishment coming back in. And if you’re telling me our project, this project has a 0% chance of influencing policy, but has a really good chance of handing the country to the Democrats, I’m out. And he goes on to say, that’s not a good prospect for liberty. So handing the country over to Democrats, what do you what do you say to that?

Heise: Yeah, a few things. So, one, we’re now at an existing Ron Paul world with that because what happened in 2008 and 2012, we all got behind Ron Paul. He got [expletive] They held his delegates on a bus, they didn’t show him in second place on the media. Like, all this crazy stuff that happened, and then we all said, “Screw these people.” And Obama got two terms and nobody said [expletive] about it back then. And so one I also think that even from his tactical position of let’s run Massie through the GOP, it’s a very self-defeating argument. I’m sure you’ve heard the idea before of like if you’re in a negotiation with somebody and you’re at the negotiating table, if you’re not capable of getting up and saying [expletive] you and walking out, then you are captive, you are automatically the weaker party in that negotiation and that’s what that’s doing.

So what you’re saying is he also said that he wouldn’t support anybody from the administration in the GOP but we can’t have Democrats. So it’s kind of this frenetic thing that I don’t know where that lands you, maybe he just sits the cycle out.

I don’t know, but it also puts you in this weak position of basically saying I’m captive so go ahead and put the screws to Massie the way you already did to Ron Paul because there’s not really going to be a price to pay for that you know like and so I’m going to fall in line. And then furthermore what I would say is it really when you start to game theory it out it puts Dave personally in a weird position. Dave has been the guy who has again I’m singing his praise.

I listen to all of his content pretty much like he is very effectively you know destroyed the lobby, open up the conversation, destroyed the narrative on Gaza, the history of Israel Palestine, just all of these really important things that are absolute red meat in the today’s political environment.

And then where is this going to land him? Okay, I won’t support JD Vance, but if they put if they put DeSantis up now Dave, is Dave going to support that Zionist after three years of being that guy? It just doesn’t make sense. And so I think what we have to do, and this is where I really appreciate Nick Fuentes. I appreciate Nick Fuentes as an analyst. Nick Fuentes says hates us as libertarians, but I really like his reads a lot.

And Nick Fuentes understands that understands something that the past libertarians understood and that we do have to incorporate which is that we’re not going to win on appeal.

These systems of power, they don’t win by winning the debate. We’ve won all the debates. We’re winning all the debates and yet we’re losing all of the [expletive] fights. And so we have to embrace that and understand that the only thing that these systems and these politicians and these power centers respond to is not a strong argument. That’s for the people.

That’s for the culture. The power systems respond to leverage and power and pain. And so what I favor most, like if I had just like my total fantasy of what this looks like, I do agree with Scott that there’s, you know, several people out there that could be good candidates, and so I would love to see a situation like this. Ran Paul runs in the Republican primary. Joe Kent runs in the Republican primary. We go to bat because if you’re running the Republican primary, you’re running to win.

You’re not running to get ballot access – you’re running to win! That’s the upside, right? That’s the whole point. And so you do it. But then you say, you’re going to give us these very important things that matter to the young people of this country, that matter to the independents of this country, that matter to libertarians of this country, blah, all of that stuff, you’re going to give us this or you’re going to face Massie and Marjorie Taylor Green in the general and you will lose and we don’t [expletive] care.

You’re going to get what we want no matter what. That is the strong position, and so if he hands the party to the Democrats, we are already running off the fiscal cliff, dude. Like that the culture is already deteriorating. It didn’t get better under Trump. The right is divided because of the betrayal. Like I don’t see a path.

It’s not like we’re on a path to something good and then the Democrats will just you know ruin the party for everybody. We’re in a bad spot. Like we’re in a bad spot and we have to it’s going to take some joker energy like that. And Fuentes understands that too. Fuentes isn’t going in there saying oh you know let’s let’s go take over the GOP but if it doesn’t work out you know we’re going to have to support Marco Rubio. No, he’s saying if they don’t give us what we want, [expletive] them.

Vote Democrat because that’s what it’s going to take. And so when you’re in a fight, and that’s what it is. This stuff isn’t, oh, just some conversations. It’s a fight over power and how it’s used. When you’re in a fight, you’re going to get [expletive] punched. And people need to start understanding that kind of stuff.

I think that’s the only way they learn. That’s the only way they ever actually get better. You know, we’re going to get punched, too, because we’re the smaller fighter. We’re middleweights fighting heavyweights.

Nate: I just I think to say like something like what Dave said, which I don’t know Dave, but to say that he has to like truly believe that Massie is going to run in the primary and win and then he’s going to go on to be president and that this is somehow the worst option. I just don’t see that at all. I don’t think Republicans even have a chance of winning in 28 right now. Honestly, I think we’re maybe a chance. We’ll see. We’ll see.

Heise: Hang on. Let me push back a little bit. Look, here’s why. Go ahead. 60 days into Trump term two would if we would go back to that day, day 60, and you say, “Guys, in two years, it’s going to be a Democrat cleanup.”

You know what I mean? Like, it’s going to be a Democrat House, Democrat Senate, all of this stuff. The vibes were high as [expletive] at that time, like you know everybody like it looked like this was going to be real like there was a little window you know in that beginning portion where it was real and so everybody would have told you that this is impossible.

No, we’re not. No way. And yet they betrayed everybody and here we are and the impossible is possible. And what are you seeing on the Democrat side right now? The establishment is beating the populace for this positions. The lobby is backing the establishment.

They’re it and you’re seeing the populace and the young Turks fight it out over there. And so it’s going to suck really bad for them for two years, too. Don’t get it twisted.

Democrats didn’t win because people are just Democrats all of a sudden. They win because a self-respecting population can’t take the level of betrayal that they were given by the GOP. They’re not married to these people.

They’re just the same way they weren’t married to the GOP or to Trump. And so I don’t know. I don’t like this whole, oh, it’s fate that they’re going to win because we’ve already seen this crazy whiplashing snapback kind of thing. And so, I don’t see any reason to believe that can’t happen again.

Nate: Yeah, I don’t believe it’s fate. I think I’m just going by the Trump administration is still going to be in in charge the next couple years, and I’ve seen how they handled the previous couple years. And I don’t maybe they make this massive turnaround, and it really depends on how smart the Democrats play it. Like they can act fairly normal and just care about, you know, the needs of a lot of people and of course the Trump will just be the one stopping them from creating the utopia in America and that’ll be their advertisement for 2028, or Trump could continue doing some of the things he’s been doing over the last couple years and the de Democrats could be able to make a lot of really good valid points about how stupid all of it is, and people could just be ready for something else in 28. I’m not saying it’s fate. It’s for sure going to happen.

I just wouldn’t say that. I wouldn’t be convinced that if you ran a third party, a big third party in 28 that would be the reason that the country gets handed over to Democrats. I think Republicans are doing a fine job on their own, obviously, handing the country over to Democrats right now. I would not I would not blame it on someone else showing what the better option is. I think it at the very least, like you said, like with the negotiating position here, you got to be willing to go all the way, they need a brutal wakeup call at the very least.

Heise: And another element to this, now I’m not saying it’s bigger on the left than it would be on the right, but that the people are underestimating the degree like what is Thomas Massie’s superpower? What is Joe Kent’s superpower? What is Tucker Carlson’s superpower?

Their superpower is their ability to bring together otherwise disperate groups of people. I mean, I’ve seen multiple segments of like Cenk Uygur, a Medicare for all left populist leftist saying, well, you know, Thomas Mass is the only one with a spine and the only one with a soul in the frigin Congress. I would support him if he ran.

Those people are not voting in the primary. That’s why he’s getting 10% in the general and 2% in the primary as far as the data has to say right now. And so to run him through that general, you’re constraining his biggest superpower. It’s like chopping the arm off. You know what I mean? Like he doesn’t have access to that or the coalition that would support him isn’t there. But yeah, you’re totally right that the Republicans are doing a good job of giving it to the left as well.

Roger Stone and trap narratives

Nate: So Scott Horton has some stuff to say on that episode as well, and I thought it’d be good to get a response out there to some of the things he said, he did call you compare you to Roger Stone and said that you were falling into a trap and basically that you were trying to ruin Thomas Massie’s career essentially, so you’re I wanted to get your response to some of that and then obviously Scott came with a bunch of legal analysis with whether or not this is something that could actually be done. And so whatever part of that you want to respond to or add.

Heise: Yeah. So I’ll do that one first. Like I’m not saying this in any bad way. I’m saying this in the best way. Thomas Massie just ruined his own political career. And it’s a hero absolutely heroic thing that he did.

And I’m not just saying that. He is the one who went out there when he was doing when he was starting the Epstein files thing and said, “I might lose my political career over this, but it was worth it.”

And so, at some point doing what’s right and doing what’s the best by the country is better than the thing that gives you more status. I guess that’s the important thing here, as far as Roger Stone and James Buchanan and that hand of the election, I really think again there’s like this theme that we’re talking here of like young people and they don’t have their interest. I think that sounds like some okay boomer stuff. Like I really do.

Again, it’s a completely different world. Like nobody gives a [expletive] about Roger Stone at this point. I hear him. The lesson is well, he handed the thing to the Democrats, but again, you’re coming from that presupposition of we can’t have the Democrats. Well, now you’re captive and we’re back in the circle. So you now all of a sudden you have libertarians propping up the uni-party.

You know what I mean? Like and when the uni-party just iced our freaking guy betrayed everyone didn’t like and it’s not even that they just betrayed us as libertarians. They betrayed the reddest of red meats in their base by not giving deportations. These people don’t give a [expletive] And you know what I mean. Like it’s crazy.

And so again, I just don’t think it’s the same world. And if the proposition to young people who do not have, you know, they don’t have houses. They’re being replaced at work. There’s this race resentment thing that’s growing because of who’s replacing the jobs. They don’t have investments. Like the jobs don’t pay.

They can’t afford life. And so it’s like, oh, I’m going to shoot for what I want within politics. And if I don’t get it, rich people are going to have to pay my maternity leave. I think and Scott’s here saying, “Oh, we can’t have the left.” I think that sounds like okay boomer to these people, and again, you have to be willing to you have to be willing to go out on your shield to really fight a real battle. Anyway, yeah.

Nate: I mean, one thing you said there really hit me. It’s so wild after everything we’ve gone through over the last couple years, sticking your neck out for Trump and you know, but I voted for him. I did, and then I happened to vote for him the time that we get the Iran war and oh by the way he knocks Thomas Massie out of office and it was like that just my luck, right?

You know, it’s like buying a stock right before it crashes or something like that, and for the result of that to be and so that’s why we got to get more active in the Republican party at a time when all of the best people are leaving.

Heise: So one thing with this whole American Liberty Party project is I’m not going to name names. I won’t betray confidences and all of that stuff, but we have America First statewide candidates and their teams coming to us saying it’s [expletive] impossible. Yeah. Like they’re like they’re the ones coming to us saying no, it’s a stonewall. It can’t be done. We have to do this.

The people who actually engage the mechanisms of these things, the things that the logistics of these things are the ones who are coming to us and saying no, we have to do this. So the people who actually tried it are the ones who are walking away, the ones who are staying is not Thomas Massie, it’s Marco Rubio. You know what I mean? Like and all of that stuff. So, you’re sitting here trying to say, “Oh, let’s do that.” When those people are leaving. I don’t get it.

Nate: I mean, like I guess in some sense I’ll say I understand that like you said earlier like I like Republicans better than the left.

Heise: And I would argue, you know, I do too. Like I like Republicans culturally more than the left. But at the end of the day, this is not this is way more than a debate. It’s a debate in the media sphere. It’s a debate in podcast world. But in the real world, in the systems world, this is a war.

This is a fight. You know what I mean? Like, and this is well beyond debate. And when you’re going to do that, yeah, you got to you’re going to have to be willing to go out on your shield because these people are ruthless.

The legality of party renaming, Constitution Party precedents

Nate: What about the stuff that Scott was saying about Michigan and New York? And he was saying this many states out of that many states don’t allow this and that and so is this thing even possible in the first place.

Heise: Yeah, so let’s talk about that. This is my favorite piece about it. And you know Scott said he prefaced what he had to say by saying he loves me and I’ll say I love him back, you know and preface what I have to say with that, what I will say is that I’ve seen a lot of this tactic inside the Libertarian Party from the leftist inside of the party where if it’s like I don’t agree with a thing or I don’t like something, I’m just going to declare it illegal and scare everybody away, you know, nothing of what he said is accurate. Frankly, there’s one thing that he said that’s accurate, which is that Richard Winger is the foremost expert on all of this stuff, that is true. That is absolutely true. Unfortunately for him, Richard Winger’s public work does not back up what he said. I mean, pretty much all he said from that is you have states that have to go out and get petitions to maintain ballot access and go out and get votes to maintain ballot access.

And that’s just what it takes to stay as what’s called a recognized party within a given state, and then somehow superimpose that to say if you go to change the name that you automatically have to do all of this stuff. The problem is that it’s not supported by the historical record and it’s not supported by Winger’s work.

So two things there. One, it’s a moot point. It’s a moot point. It doesn’t even matter to me right now. What matters to me is changing the National Party brand and the National Party name.

There is political reasons for that as well as precedent reasons for that go into Richard Winger’s work, but this idea that like because think about it like I’m there is if to what I’m saying like if Massie would actually run and then we go and do this thing if you were to go to the national convention and then change the name to the American Liberty Party, change it to the Americana Eagle and all of this stuff and then Massie runs right at that point. What did I say earlier? He’s polling 10%. You’re you have real a real shot at debates, you have a real shot at not just minor but major party status. That’s everything and every like that’s everything at that point. The idea that like in the midst of that you would go and do this state level thing at the same time and complicated and cut it up that’s crazy.

That’s something that you do during peace time and so can you do it? Well, this is where he should read more Richard Winger. It’s already been done. That’s the crazy thing about what he said. It’s already been done, the Constitution Party was not called the Constitution Party for quite a while. It was called the US Taxpayers Party.

And then in 1999, the National Party first, it’s important that the National Party does it first. The National Party first changed their name. Okay? And at that time, they had a lot more state ballots than they do today. They had like 39 state ballots at that point, and so then subsequently, there was a couple states that just didn’t want to do it, they wanted to stay as like the independent party of whatever, but every state, something like 35 states that went to change their name in compliance with the national party was allowed to change their name and allowed to keep their state recognition. Okay?

All but one. And so, so then you might hone in on the one and say, “Oh, well, Mike, you know, that one could be really important.” Yeah. That’s why you wait until peace time because in this hypothetical you get the 5% you get the matching funds and then you can peacemeal that stuff. But the idea again that you would just do this complicated thing while Massie’s running and making history is just asine. No one ever said that. So in other words that it can be done.

It’s not even the first step like first step is getting this thing going at the national level, because that’s the best signal. That is the we are changing things. We’re serious. We want you here. We want to leave the baggage behind. All of that and basically make it more of a home for that bigger, wider America first movement that’s already shifting these elections around.

So you do that, you rally around Massie and then he gets the 5 to 10%. Then you worry about that stuff later, which there’s already a historical precedent. And the foremost historian of that is Richard Winger. And Winger’s work shows a hundred different times that parties have changed names. Like Scott made a very particular a couple of very particular claims of like, oh well, if you go to change the name, it’s going to trigger all of this repetitioning. In order to make a claim like that, there would have to be some kind of like statutory footprint that says that.

And the problem with that claim is that there’s only five states in the entire country that have any statutory footprint about name changes and what happens and what the process is whatsoever. 45 states have nothing to say, they’re silent on it. And so Winger’s work also shows in addition to that historical president that’s separate from that there are 16 states that are silent on it that allowed name changes and allowed them to keep their state recognized status. So that’s a different context. That is not the context of following suit with the National Party. It’s the context of if the Libertarian Party of Pennsylvania right here today while being part of the National Party wanted to change their name to the Communist Party of Pennsylvania, that’s the context in which those other examples happen. So it’s just crazy.

It’s absolutely crazy. And what he did well – let me address the other claim. The other claim was oh mic drop, you can’t use the word America in New York and that’s illegal. Again, this is something that is being said to scare people that don’t know what they’re talking about cuz no normal person is looking at the statutes of name changes and this kind of stuff like you have to be crazy to do this kind of stuff.

And so while that is true, you cannot use the name America. But what he’s leaving out that nobody thinks about is that a state party of any kind does not have to follow the name this the exact same naming conventions of its national party. So like right now the what is recognized as the Libertarian Party of New Hampshire is not called the Libertarian Party of New Hampshire. It’s called the Granite State Libertarians. As in my example earlier there were multiple states called the independent party of X state Y state that were a part under the umbrella of the national US taxpayers party which then became the Constitution Party and so you just use a compliant name.

Nate: You just do the Liberty Party of New York. I just go a Liberty Party and it just says a Liberty Party on the thing and I think that works out pretty well.

Strategic goals and competition

Heise: But what he’s doing there is he’s doing something that Dave Smith himself accuses a lot of people of doing and he’s right when he points it out is that he’s working backwards from a predetermined conclusion.

And that conclusion is that we have to for whatever reason we have to continue to prop up the uniart system. We have to do this through the GOP, and we don’t want to do the new path thing that Tucker who they’re all friends with started. So, like that’s what he’s doing. And so, he’s working backwards from there to then sloppily scare people away from this, turn people off from this, cow them back into the GOP, and yeah, I don’t get it.

Nate: Yeah. I mean, I think if they’re really concerned with protecting the Republican Party, I would say you want the Republican Party to get better. And I don’t think they get better by Massie or anyone in the primary because then they end up losing and then Rubio gets to the general and then everyone decides, well, we got to vote for Rubio because it’s not AOC or whoever else.

And then what does the party actually learn? I think they actually can learn something by having some stiff competition on the ballot. Something all the way through the general where both parties, both major parties can see wow, there really is an appetite for that.

You know what I do? Maybe we ought to start offering some of that from some of our people. Maybe we should take this under consideration. And then they end up getting better. And guess what? We’re all better off for it because we don’t have to suffer under whatever the next worst version of those parties is going to be.

And we need a second party.

Heise: So, last thing I’ll say is I will I won’t lie because we’re all friends. We have been friends for years and all of that stuff. And I love and respect Scott and his work and his books and his mastery of foreign policy and cite him every day and all that stuff.

I can’t help but take it personally though because this conversation has been had. So like when Scott Horton’s on there saying, “Oh, Michael’s accusing me of not listening.” this conversation has been had, you know, like or the idea like Bret Weinstein didn’t just up and out of the ether announce that was the culmination of a multi-monthl long process of going around and having conversations from every end of audience centers, let’s say, of every end of the America First movement, and I take it personally because to think that oh yeah, is it can I do it? Like I’ve never I’ve never been told what I’m doing is illegal before.

You know what I mean? Like it happens every [expletive] day in this party because these people can’t make an argument. They can’t put forward a vision. They can’t put forward a plan of argument. So they have to just say it’s illegal for you. So I’ve well experienced the steelmanning the legal arguments.

To think that I would talk to people around Tucker Carlson without having done that is insane. That I would embarrass myself like that. Like that’s crazy. Yeah. Like oh I forgot to check whether or not this was even possible. My bad.

audience feedback

Nate: Well, I know we’re we’re at an hour now, man. So, I want you to tell everyone where they can go. Like, what do you need? Time out.

Heise: Is there any chats?

Nate: We’ve got chats.

Heise: Yeah, I’ve been I’ve been reading through them, but also not wanting to I know I said an hour, but we could do some chats. Interrupt the conversation, let me see here.

Nate: Chris, let’s see. Chris Mir said, “If it’s only a small number of states a problem with the name change, then focus on them later and probably becomes more aware from the movement in other states.” all right. Agree with that one, let’s see. We got would still have LP in the name. So, there you go. Consolation prize for the LP people, if you need that, sorry.

Some people have been chatting back and forth with each other. So, I’m trying to find ones that are more directed toward Oh, there is a question about Give me the hate. Oh, we probably got some hate in here. Let me put this one up here first. This one was from earlier that I wanted to put up.

Maintaining ideological purity

Nate: Ed’s perspective says, “Is there any effort to teach the libertarian philosophy and Austrian economics to the new people like Bret without any effort from these newcomers to learn the libertarianism? I fear this pushes DOA.”

So that goes back to something I was talking to you about earlier. Like my biggest fear is if this party becomes something that’s just got a bunch of socialists in their commies or just becomes another Republican party like okay I don’t I’m not excited anymore. I don’t I don’t have any reason to support this and I’ve got pretty strict principled voting rules and you know I don’t want Medicare for all to be coming from the from any of these people or anything Democrat policy. So what like what can you say to put people’s mind at ease on that whole front?

Heise: Yeah. So again this getting to the point where we’re at now was the culmination of a multi-monthlong process and that process is still underway, and so you might ask like how does this motley crew of people be held together?

And here’s the conversations that I’ve had with people successfully is that it looks something like this, you kind of have three layers, three things that kind of bind people together: One, a coalition party has to have a coalition board. Everybody has to have a seat at the table to, you know, fight for their interests. That’s number one. Everyone has skin in the game, two also mentioned already – that there’s already a core of things that has brought this people together that they care so much about that they are shifting elections around in a nonpartisan way for those interests and all of that is red meat to libertarians the spending the waste that you know that was all the doge stuff the no new wars immigration sorry open borders people but you know you can’t have open immigration and all of this stuff and so everyone gets skin in the game.

Everyone has this core of things that they already agree with each other on that is binding them together. So everyone has skin in the game. Everyone wins together. And then the third layer is okay well they are disperate groups and they are going to have like a different value hierarchy on these issues like does an Hasparians people value and the Fed the same way that I do as a libertarian like this kind of thing. And so what has been discussed there is that everybody gets a pet project from their respective group that makes it into like the platform of this thing so long as that pet project is tolerable by everybody else in the group. So like your example there I can tell you right now when I had conversations with these people I even said that exact same thing.

I was like I think I could speak for everybody else where it’s like we’re out on Medicare for all like that can’t be it. And you know what they said that’s fine. We don’t want that. We want money in politics and so that is a populist issue, yeah, we should be we should not be our elections should be more represent representative of something other than corporations and foreign lobbies, yeah, you know and all of that. And so we their argument and this was unanimous. This wasn’t a debate like this was just given up like we don’t have a democracy and all bets are off until that point, going through.

Funding and logistical hurdles

Nate: So, a lot of these people have been talking back and forth with each other. So, I did get a boomer suck in there. It says boomer suck from Mickey from somebody who looks like a boomer.

Heise: Self-hating boomer, bro.

Nate: I appreciate it. Oh, she’s great. She’s great, let me see here. Good Tennessee people hanging out. I had someone in here that said to stop hating on the boomers in here, too. So, I was going to put that on.

Heise: I gave my disclaimer. Yeah, I gave my disclaimer.

Nate: Maybe they forgot.

Heise: Yeah, it’s not all boomers, but man, do they have some pattern? Not everyone, but the numbers the number, you know, in general, if you’re a betting if you’re a betting man, you would be right.

Nate: Or if you’re a strategizing if you’re a strategizing man. Someone mentioning this would be very expensive. Libertarian Revolution 7026, which I think is about what the LP is on track for right now. 7026. So, starting a new separate party called the American Liberty Party would be extremely difficult and expensive. The cost could run. It’s going to be pretty expensive, right?

Heise: Absolutely. But it depends on what your goals are. If your goals are to again go into a pitched battle with the multi-billion dollar machine head on, yeah, you’re going to get [expletive] up, so the goal is where can you get the wins? Once you accept that premise that I said earlier of like America first even in the broadest sense cannot win elections on their own, you are now talking about political guerrilla warfare and political asymmetric warfare, and so libertarian candidates as well as not and not just libertarian candidates, dissident candidates; I would broaden it and out to the Casey Putsch and the Monty Fritts and all of this stuff. They have a very strong what’s called dollar-to-vote ratio. And so if you can just ratchet that up a little bit, but you also have to be very targeted.

Now again, I’ll tell you a part of my conversation that I had with Massie personally face to face, the going back to the analog that the best analog unfortunately is Gary Johnson. Gary Johnson had a lot of disadvantages compared to what Massie has right now, right?

Like he didn’t have the media environment. I would argue that’s the number one. That’s tens of millions of dollars right there. Like the idea of Tucker Carlson who has publicly said he would support Massie publicly once a new party, the idea that he would have supported Gary Johnson back in 2016 was just not in the map.

Like that was just not and that there’s gold right there, but Gary Johnson again going into it was polling at 1%. And then at his peak pulled at 12%, pulled in about 12 to 13 million, and that then boiled down to three and a half% and that was also within a context where Gary Johnson was well removed from office. He was well removed from the headlines, well removed from relevancy and all of that. None of that and you know he was kind of a goofball. He was sticking his tongue out of people like you know all of this stuff that you’re not going to get with Massie where you with the strengths that you have with Massie is he’s he strength isn’t just that he’s the libertarian guy. It’s that he is he’s at a nexus point of the whole culture.

Like he is the Libertarian guy and the Epstein guy and the MAHA guy and the Green guy and the Anti-War guy. And so he like so literally the entire America First movement minus Nick Fuentes wants him. You know what I mean? Like and so he already raised $25 million. And so if you’re polling at 10% to start, you already have all these examples, have that media environment and you can you know I think he if he raised $25 million can he raise 50 60 70 million I don’t see any reason why not and so are does anyone truly believe that Thomas Massie in this situation can’t get 1.5% more than Gary Johnson in 2016? It’s crazy talk, dude.

Like and so I think when you consider all that yes, it’s expensive. $50 million is a lot of money, but it’s not a lot of money in real politics. That’s just real money in libertarian or a lot of money in real a lot of money in libertarian world, and so if you could spend $50 million and now you have at least a minor party if not a major party the all the component parts of what that creates is the important thing. And again this all goes into what I talked to him and why I suspect he said that this is one of the plans on breaking points. So at that point, what does it mean to get the 5%. Like that doesn’t just happen in a vacuum. That happens in a situation where you have amassed an email list of multiple millions of people.

You have amassed a donor list of hundreds of thousands of donors, you know, he had seven figure donors to his super PAC in the primary. And so now you have a war chest and you have a group of people that supports this thing and you just landed in this hypothetical this historic victory. So, can you then raise $30 $40 million to the party? Okay, $30 $40 million is not a lot of money, but what if you took that money, you worked with a data firm, and you modeled out where are the mo the 15 to 20 most purple districts in the entire country. Yes, you have races like AOC or Matt Gaetz or Thomas Massie where there’s a shitload of money being pumped in, but in any ordinary race like any ordinary house district around the country, a couple million dollars is a lot of [expletive] money. Yeah.

And so all of a sudden, if you have $50 million and you have ten fifteen targets and you use data to do that and now you’re pumping that money in to make sure every door is knocked, you know, all and running a real race, then can you get a wedge of people into the house? Maybe can you do that while also doing, you know, shameless self plug, the project decentralized revolution because you have to keep the pipeline going. You have to keep delivering good news. You have to keep all that stuff going. You have to you have to deliver good news to people because they’re fickle and it’ll fizzle. We’ve seen that, right?

And so like that’s kind of the answer to that question is that you can if you have that new environment you can do a lot with relatively less just once you accept that you are not going out in with the expectation of being a third of Congress. You are guerilla war fighters and guerilla war fighters tend to have a pretty good [expletive] track record when it comes to empires. Absolutely. I gota How many of these do you want to do by the way?

Nate: I’ve been going through I’ll let you know. Yeah, I’m good. Yeah, good question.

Final thoughts and call to action

Nate: Pat Carlson says, “Are you worried that if the American Liberty Party fails, it could ruin the LP?” Are you concerned about the LP here? Compared to what? Yeah. I mean, it’s as simple as that. What do you mean by ruin the LP? I thought that happened a few years ago. Yeah. No, the LP is ruined, unfortunately.

Heise: So, but put it this way. It’s like if I can if I can do this gambit and have a even a decent chance of doing it, but the cost of that is like the Libertarian party weakens in the long run. I’m swinging on the upside there, guys. Sorry. I What does it even mean weaken? Like you just said, compared to what?

From nothing to nothinger like that they’re not they’re not using any leverage. They’re they’re not close to winning anything in so like a weekend. What does that mean? They just sold they just sold their headquarters for financial reasons and the past 3 months they are negative4 to $50,000 a month. Like I if this pattern the past three months continues to build out they’re going to be bankrupt before we ever even get to the next convention. And so I don’t I don’t even know what ruin means, the that goes back to one of those difficult truths.

Libertarians, small L, in general, the Liberty movement doesn’t give a [expletive] about the Libertarian Party. We don’t even have our own people maintenancing and engaging with and upkeeping the party. So, it just becomes this lowest common denominator thing. So, again, yeah, I don’t I don’t know what that means.

Nate: John Thorp says, “I’m telling you, too many people hate the LP because of its past. If not a brand change, then a massive overhaul of the leadership.” unfortunately, Yeah, I was going to say the leadership kind of just went maybe in the opposite direction that you would want it to go, now I’ve known one of them for a long time, a member of our group, like if you listen to my show, Good Morning Liberty, you go listen to a few episodes of it and realize that one of the new leaders of the party is in our private group and has been there every single day listening to us talk and make fun of people for an hour at a time, and had a good time doing it. And so, okay, they haven’t been there in a few months. I’ll say that, but that I don’t, you know, I still think overall the Libertarian Party is going in the wrong direction, especially after what I saw at the convention.

Heise: I think it goes back to this thing that I said earlier that people are not grappling with is that the founding charter of the party doesn’t hold water in today’s world. And I defended that charter for years. You know what I mean? Like, but you have to update with what’s what’s going on. The idea that the party is this vehicle for the message is dead. Dave Smith is the vehicle for the message.

Scott Horton is the vehicle for the message. The podcasters are the vehicle for the message. Social media influencers are the vehicle for the message. The party cannot serve that function anymore, and so it has to deliver something in the political world now to even justify its own existence. And I think everyone feels this on an intuitive level, but no one’s like putting Yeah, putting words to it. And so that’s why it’s in a death spiral.

Nate: That’s why I still just this takeover attempt like American Liberty Party or whatever. I still recommend as I have for years now on my other show, the Libertarian Party needs to change its name. It needs to get away from that. I it is too difficult for them to be trying to message this philosophy or political ideology. The people that run the Republican party are not concerned with that. They’re not trying to teach people about Republicanism or they hate their own platform. They’ve got plenty of people on it and their platform changes. There’s no, you know, it’s just I get the idea that you want it to remain principle, but the infighting, the purity testing has kept everyone laser focused on destroying themselves this entire time.

Heise: Once you accept what I’m saying that libert the libertarian party now in today’s world be and it’s a good thing, guys. That’s the thing. I’m not saying this in a bad way. That is a na is an organ what I’m describing is an organic result of the media dying like that. Like that is a very good thing. It’s why libertarian positions and libertarian ideas are more popular than ever.

Maybe they’re not connecting it to the NAP and property rights and all that stuff, but more people are against the Fed than ever. More people are against the wars than ever. More people are against like all kinds of things. It’s why this there’s so much red meat in that shared center, but once you accept that fact and we now have to actually engage politics in this guerrilla warfare style, there are certain things that are true that people are just uncomfortable with like if what I’m about to say the people who lead the party now would be like e which is that it’s about power and people will say well libertarians don’t want power we want to destroy power you know look at Frodo we threw the ring yeah the but everyone skips the part where for three whole books and three whole movies, he had to bear the ring to do what’s right first. And you know what? You know what got him through that?

It wasn’t his political philosophy. It was his character. And so you need that was able to resist it to even get to the point of trying to destroy it. And that is what makes Massie the champion. And it’s why I think when he gets the data, even though it’s going to be the less sexy thing, it’s not going to get as many clicks, it’s not going to draw the conversation, that he knows that it’s better to do what’s right than to do what’s popular.

Nate: Yeah, let me see. Jackal Island Creature says the way Massie’s talking, he’s 100% running or willing to run if we do the ground work. And it is interesting. He I saw the breaking points clip, he didn’t rule that out or anything and he did list this as one of the potentials. I would also say he has not listed he didn’t then say or if that doesn’t happen I’ll just run as a libertarian for the Libertarian party, he didn’t say that, let me point that out to people that it does sound like he is interested in doing something.

Heise: And let me use that what you just said to pose a question because I think this is the question before the party as it stands now and they’re going to refuse to answer the question but we all know what their actual answer is so like Massie has liked many of my posts about the state of the party and how the party would need to change if M forget the caucus forget the ALP thing forget us forget our efforts forget all of that for a second if Massie independent of any of us just said you know what I’m running as a libertarian and then said, “I’m running as a libertarian and I need every single one of my people to come in.” The Libertarian Party would cease to exist as we understand it today. Yeah. There’s 8,500 members. It’s nothing. And so it would automatically he has more max donors than that. Like like he it would automatically shift to the right.

It would just it would be like what the border was doing to Texas, like it’s and so what people need to grapple with is a what if Massie but more important than Massie I like cuz I don’t want to speak for him and I do not I’m willing to take all the heat all the dirt Massie would never be involved in any of this crap should not be involved in this crap but the bigger thing than Massie is his base the people that we need in do they agree with me or the status quo of the party more about the state of the party and if they agree with me more than the status quo of the party, do you still want Massie? And if the organic result, regardless of me or you or the caucus or any of this stuff, if the organic result of the part of Massie running was a huge flood in that then shifted the party to the right. Do you still want Massie? I’m willing to bet we know the answer to that question to the current status quo of the party. And in fact, the communications director just didn’t answer it on a stream with Larry Sharp last night.

Nate: They’re it’s a weird thing like this social club aspect of the party or they just like to get around and play bureaucrat or whatever it is that they do, it’s it’s a wild thing that you know I just went to my first national this year and my god it’s a it’s so much worse than I ever imagined and totally disheartening for the future of the movement.

Heise: I had a conversation with a America first governor candidate recently who wants to be supportive, and the way I worded it to him where there was like a click was the state the country is in a dire position. Like we’ve talked about all this stuff with young people and the economy and affordability and the political pretenses are getting scary. Like they’re just openly not giving a [expletive] about the consent of the govern or the will of the people or any of this stuff, and so we’re we’re entering into like an increasingly dark period, an increasingly hopeless period, and in that situation, the third most ballot present institution in the country is in the hands of these people. Does that seem responsible to anybody of any political philosophy? The answer is no, like and yeah, this is like I feel like some Thomas Jefferson coming up like it is our duty to do this, you know, for the future. Dude, I’ve been chilling.

That’s like that’s the other thing is I don’t want to do this. I when I walked away, I’ve been at home hanging out with my family, nerding out. Unbelievable levels of nerding out. Like I don’t I don’t want to do this. Like this is [expletive] Godfather 3 for me. Yeah. You know what I mean? Like I don’t want to do this, but the opportunity is there and I find myself being the country’s foremost expert on taking over a third party in a moment where where in a moment where there’s a huge demand for it and some of the biggest voices in the country want such a thing. And so I’m just answering the call and to that extent I don’t even get what the controversy is.

Nate: If Tucker Carlson and Massie and Marjorie are all there saying, “We need a new party,” and you have tens of millions of people saying, “We need a new party.” What the [expletive] are we even talking about? Just do it.

Heise: Yep. Just do it.

Nate: Where can everyone go to get involved with this, by the way, if they decide to just do it?

Heise: I don’t think I have it put in the thing I can put up on the screen, but we can put it in the show notes for everyone, americanlibertyparty.com. That’s it. Just sign Just go there, fill out the form. We still have organizers. They are onboarding people right now. There’s already some states getting some fear up, communications director last night said that membership is up.

Could be a Bret bump, you know, and all of that. And so it’s 8,500 members. This is nothing if you can’t I if we can’t if the country here’s the blackest pill for me is if in this environment with this level of dire situation with this level of disgust and distrust and dismay of the government with the biggest figures in the country wanting a new party and people looking for a new avenue if we can’t do this we’re just not in enough pain yet as a country. Yeah. Yeah. It’s going to have to get a lot worse.

Nate: Totally agree. I’m worried, you know, I’ve worried for a while that’s what’s going to come to have that, you know, Argentina moment or whatever, but maybe it doesn’t have to, you know, could be another option. So, Michael, thank you for doing this tonight. I know you got some other big interviews lined up, so we’re all excited about that.

Heise: I’ll be on with I’m recording with Dave Smith tomorrow.

Nate: Awesome. So, good luck with that. I hope it goes well. Hope everyone is still friends afterwards. And, you know, once this all succeeds and Massie’s running, I’m sure you’ll be a upstanding guy and you will allow Dave and Scott to come back into the party and help out with some stuff. I’m sure once they apologize.

Heise: So, even if they don’t, even if they don’t.

Nate: Anyway, man, thank you so much for hanging out, good luck with your interviews coming up and everyone go to the links in the show notes to help out with this.

Heise: So, thank thanks a lot, dude. Thanks, Nate.

Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X