Social LibertySocial Liberty

What a Party Is For

Michael Heise built the Mises Caucus's Decentralized Revolution, a plan for hundreds of local candidates, and now proposes one convention vote in El Paso.

Social Liberty Foundation ·

Click to enlarge

Dave Smith’s line, as the host read it to Michael Heise on November 18, was that Ron Paul ran as a libertarian and nobody cared, then ran as a Republican and changed everyone’s path forever. Heise’s answer took no time to find its example. In 2012, he said, nobody knew what the Federal Reserve was, and knowing it made you a conspiracy theorist. Now, he said, every five-year-old with a phone knows. Nobody running for office made that happen. Podcasters did, Smith among them.

The conversation ran an hour and twenty-three minutes on episode 176 of Decentralized Revolution, the Mises Caucus podcast, and the full transcript is here. Rebranding a Borrowed Line set out the American Liberty Party’s plan to take over the Libertarian Party and rename it. This piece takes up what Heise added when he answered Smith and Scott Horton, who have both argued that Thomas Massie should stay in the Republican Party, and what the answer looks like beside his own earlier work.

The plan before this plan

The podcast’s name is the name of a plan. After the Mises Caucus won the Libertarian national committee at Reno in 2022, it launched Project Decentralized Revolution, a strategy of recruiting and training large numbers of local candidates for city council, school board, mayor, sheriff and judge, and of using small offices to cut taxes and decline unwanted state and federal rules. The theory was that national races face stacked ballot-access laws and long odds, while a local race can be won by one organized person with a lawn sign and a list of neighbors. The caucus cited early results of about one in three local candidates winning in some cycles. Nothing in that plan needed a leader at the top, since each candidate took root in one place, answered to that place, and could be copied without permission.

Heise brought it up himself that night, calling it a “shameless self plug” and saying the pipeline of good news must keep running because people are fickle and it will fizzle. Then he spent the hour on something close to its opposite. The American Liberty Party plan is one act, at one convention, in El Paso in February 2028, in which a few hundred delegates would take an existing party with ballot lines in most states and give it a new name and a new nominee. Rebranding a Borrowed Line counted how few votes that takes. Its power comes down from a single decision and spreads out to the states by consequence.

From nothing into something

This collection of essays has a picture for the stage Heise says the country is entering. In early spring a field that looked empty in February is not one plant. Thousands of seedlings come up at once, each with the same genetic inheritance, each rooted where its seed fell, no one of them directing the others. The canopy is a late result of that, and it doesn’t come from the trunk of an older tree. First There Was One, Then There Were Two argued that the first dozen members set the character of all who follow, and a coming essay, Founders, draws those twelve seats with no one in command of the rest.

Heise’s best argument for a new party is a seedling argument. The message, he said, no longer travels through a party. It spreads through podcasters and influencers and thousands of smaller voices, and he counted the shift in opinion on Israel as their doing, with no candidate behind it. That is growth by many small plants of one kind, and it happened without a center. His coalition model has the same shape in part. Each group gets a seat on the board, a core of issues all share, and one pet project in the platform so long as the others can tolerate it. Medicare for All, he said, was waved off at once by coalition members he spoke to, and they asked for money out of politics instead.

What the plan keeps from the older tree is the trunk. A party, he argued, no longer exists to carry a message and has to earn a place by what it does in elections, which means leverage. The unit that delivers leverage in his account is the ballot line, and the ballot line is a single rooted thing that has to be won whole.

Leverage, and who is captive

Smith’s objection, as Nate Thurston read it, was that a project with no chance of influencing policy and a good chance of handing the country to Democrats was one he would leave. Heise called that the weaker side of a negotiation, since a voter who cannot walk out has nothing to trade. He said he took the point from Nick Fuentes, an analyst he reads despite Fuentes’s contempt for libertarians: power responds to leverage and pain, and the arguments have already been won.

His preferred arrangement was an ultimatum. Ron Paul and Joe Kent would run in Republican primaries to win, and the party would tell the nominee that without the demands met, Massie and Marjorie Taylor Green would run against him in the general. Thurston said he still preferred Republicans to Democrats, and doubted the Republican Party would learn from a Massie loss in a primary. Its pitch, he said, is that it is better than the other side, and that pitch survives any loss.

The arithmetic

Figures carried much of Heise’s case. Each one below is his, stated live.

  • Massie lost his primary by ten points, winning every age group under 55 and losing those over it. Heise put the average Republican primary voter’s age above sixty.
  • In Republican primary polling Massie stands at one to two percent, which Heise set beside Ron Paul in 2008. In a February three-way poll by Rich Baris he reached ten percent.
  • Gary Johnson, in 2016, polled about one to two percent early, peaked near twelve, and finished at what Heise called three and a half. Massie, he said, has what Johnson lacked: a media environment, Tucker Carlson’s stated support, $25 million already raised, and no habit of sticking out his tongue at crowds.
  • Fifty million dollars, in his telling, is “a lot of money in libertarian world” and not much in real politics. A few million is plenty in an ordinary House district, so he would use a data firm to pick the fifteen most purple districts and knock every door.

None of this was checked on air. His own “maybe you can fact check me” about the share of Trump voters who defected or stayed home drew only a “35” from the host. Two of the figures can be tested here. Johnson’s 2016 result was a little over three percent, close to Heise’s three and a half. The Rasmussen head-to-head poll he cited, with Ron Paul beating Obama in 2012, cannot be confirmed from this conversation alone.

A name that has changed before

Horton, who prefaced his legal case by saying he loved Heise, argued that Michigan and New York would stop the renaming, and that the party might lose state recognition in many places. Heise said that Richard Winger, the ballot-access historian Horton had named as the authority, supports no such reading. His main example is checkable. The U.S. Taxpayers Party became the Constitution Party in 1999, with the national party changing its name first. Heise said about thirty-five of roughly thirty-nine state parties then followed, kept recognition, and only one did not. Five states, he said, have any statute on name changes at all, and the other forty-five are silent.

The New York objection, that “America” cannot be used in a party name there, he answered another way: a state affiliate need not copy the national name. He cited the New Hampshire Libertarians, whose recognized party is the Grand State Libertarians. A New York line could read Liberty Party. Whether Winger’s published work says all this we have not confirmed, nor have we read each state’s statute. The 1999 Constitution Party change is documented, and it supports the narrower claim that a national rename has been followed by state parties before.

Who comes, and why

Two kinds of people reach a third party, and they arrive for different things. Voters come out of disgust. Gary Johnson took about 3.3 percent in 2016, with Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump both widely disliked. Jo Jorgensen took about 1.2 percent in 2020, and Chase Oliver under half a percent in 2024. Heise’s pitch is built on the same material. Those he wants, he said, are not libertarians in the capital-L sense or they would already be in the party, and what joined them was betrayal, corruption, wars and spending.

Members come for a vision, and it’s a narrow one. David Nolan founded the party in 1971 around a specific idea, in reaction to wage and price controls and the draft. People who join and stay tend to hold that idea closely, which is one source of the fights over purity that Heise says come from a party trying to be an ideology as well. Murray Rothbard left over a version of the same fight in 1989.

A party gets a small core with a vision and a large, shifting edge of voters who are fed up, and the edge leaves when it’s asked for the vision it came to avoid. Heise’s coalition is held together on purpose by grievance and a shared list of issues. How it behaves once the disgust is spent, nothing in this conversation says.

What is left of the old tree

Heise’s case for the Libertarian Party as a vehicle was short. It holds ballot lines in most states, which, he said, Robert Kennedy Jr. spent about $30 million failing to match from scratch, and it has 8,500 members, which he called nothing. He also said it had sold its headquarters and was losing forty to fifty thousand dollars a month. His question to Libertarians who say the takeover would ruin the party was what ruin means.

A chat question that night asked whether the new party would teach newcomers like Bret Weinstein the philosophy and Austrian economics. Heise answered with the board, the shared issues and the pet projects, and nothing about teaching. In a plan where the party is not a carrier of message, the question has nowhere to land. In a field of seedlings it is the main one, since the same inheritance has to be in each plant, passed along from where it grew. He ended on Frodo. Libertarians say they want to destroy power, he said, and skip that Frodo had to carry the ring for three books first. What got him through, in Heise’s account, was character and not political philosophy.


A note on how this piece was written: every argument, source, and structural decision in this piece is ours. We chose the examples, worked out the logic connecting them, and directed what each paragraph needed to say. The sentences themselves were drafted with AI assistance from that outline and then edited by hand. We’d rather say that plainly than have a reader guess at it.

Sources: Decentralized Revolution, episode 176, Nate Thurston with Michael Heise, YouTube (November 18, 2026); Federal Election Commission, official presidential election results (2016, 2020, 2024); American Liberty Party, So What’s the Plan?.

Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X