First There Was One, Then There Were Two
Growing a movement.
Click to enlarge
In 1727 a twenty-one-year-old printer in Philadelphia gathered some acquaintances into a club for Friday evenings, and called it the Junto. The members Franklin names in his Autobiography are not what a reader would guess for a group that went on to found a lending library and, by way of an offshoot, the American Philosophical Society. Joseph Breintnall copied deeds for a scrivener. Thomas Godfrey was a glazier who taught himself mathematics. Nicholas Scull was a surveyor, William Parsons a shoemaker who had turned to surveying, William Maugridge a joiner. Hugh Meredith, Stephen Potts and George Webb worked beside Franklin in the print shop. Later came Robert Grace, a gentleman of leisure, and William Coleman, a merchant’s clerk.
No two came from the same trade. All of them read, and each would argue.
Franklin kept the number near twelve. Past that, he writes, he wanted each member to form a club of his own on the same plan, so that the Junto would spread without growing. And he gave the club a way of admitting people. Under the rules he wrote down in 1731, a candidate was asked, standing, whether he loved mankind in general, of whatever profession or religion; whether he thought any person ought to be harmed in body, name or goods for mere opinion; and whether he loved and sought truth for truth’s sake. Nobody said a word of liberty or party. The questions screened for a disposition, and the rest was left to follow.
A small population
Biologists have a name for what happens when a handful of individuals start a new population. In 1942 Ernst Mayr called it the founder effect: a few animals carried to an island hold only a sample of the genes the mainland had, and whatever the sample happened to include is what every later generation inherits, whether or not it suits the island. Traits uncommon at home can become common there, and a gene the founders lacked may never arrive.
Startups know a version of this. The first ten people in a company set what counts as a good day, who gets heard in a meeting, what a shipped product looks like, and the thirtieth hire arrives into those customs and mostly adopts them. Programmers have a phrase for the same pressure, convention over configuration, and Frameworks argued that a framework’s defaults do more to shape what gets built than anything a user decides. A group’s first members are its defaults. They aren’t a vote the later members cast at the door, they are the door.
That doesn’t make the founders a cause of what follows, because plenty else acts on a small group: a lucky year, a bad one, a rival who arrives. It does mean a movement can’t treat early membership as a headcount.
Twelve at a table
The Libertarian Party began in 1971 in David Nolan’s living room in Colorado, a handful of people around a coffee table who agreed that the two parties had stopped offering anything to somebody who held to liberty on every question. Its founding left something behind: a pledge. For decades every member signed a statement renouncing the initiation of force to achieve political or social goals. The pledge was a screen like Franklin’s three questions, set out as a single line, and for fifty years it sorted people who would sign it from those who wouldn’t.
Look at what the sorting kept and what it didn’t. It kept a party of people who valued principle over winning, and it kept them cheaply, since a pledge costs nothing to sign. It didn’t screen for the willingness to count votes, canvass a precinct, or persuade somebody who disagreed. The party’s tradition of splendid isolation, of presidential candidates who took four million votes in a good year and nothing the year after, has the look of a field’s early culture, set when the members were few and every one of them mattered.
The same openness left the door where it had been. In 2017 a group of members formed the Mises Caucus, and at Reno in 2022 it took nearly every seat on the national committee. The October 2026 announcement of the American Liberty Party proposes to do it again, on purpose, with the party’s own ballot lines as the prize. A takeover is what happens when a thing built on a screen finds a second screen.
Birney’s Liberty Party in 1840 shows the other end. It had abolitionists, and nearly nobody else. In 1844 it drew about sixty-two thousand votes, and by 1848 most of its members had walked into the Free Soil Party, which counted Whigs and Democrats who disliked slavery’s spread but would never have called themselves abolitionists. Birney’s first members were a wonderful core and an impossible base.
Three pulls
A young group wants three things from the people it lets in, and each pulls against the others.
Enough of them. Twelve people can’t run a precinct, and a ballot line takes thousands of signatures. A group that stays at the Junto’s number stays a club.
Alike enough. A group that takes anyone who shows up has no center, and the first strong personality to arrive will furnish one. Mayr’s sample goes on to be the population, whatever it contains.
Different enough. A group that takes only those like itself ends up talking to the people who already agree, which describes the Libertarian Party’s recent decades. The Junto, with its glazier and shoemaker and clerk, ran the other way, and its members were not alike even in station.
None of the three can be raised without cost to the others, and none turns into a single dial. A cause can be large and alike and narrow, large and varied and loose, or small and varied and slow, and it can’t be all three at once. Where a group stands among them, and how it moves in the years it’s small, is most of what its early history is.
Two kinds of person
Two earlier essays in this collection sorted people by a different measure, one that has nothing to do with opinions. Cultures of Life and Death borrowed a phrase from John Paul II and read it through chapter 50 of the Tao Te Ching, as two postures toward ending. Valuing the Culture of Death then went back and gave the second posture its due. Life, in that second essay, is offense: it reaches, expands, takes ground, tries the new thing and accepts the risk of losing. Death is defense: it holds, keeps, settles and guards what has been made. Both are virtues, both have practitioners, and a tree needs its growing tips and its dead heartwood alike.
People tend to lean one way. A person of the first kind sees a gap and moves toward it, and a person of the second sees what could be lost and stands in front of it. Tal and Petrosian played chess in the same decade, one sacrificing pieces for positions nobody could calculate and the other so careful that the press called his games dull, and neither was the lesser player. A hospice nurse, an archivist and a conservator practice the second posture, and a movement is lucky to have them.
For a small group at the start, though, the first posture has the better claim. Early on there is hardly anything to guard. The thing to be kept doesn’t exist yet, and the people who would keep it haven’t arrived. What a group of twelve needs from each member is reach, the willingness to bring in a friend, answer a stranger, try an event that may draw nine people, and do it again the next week without a sign it was working. Growth is the work of the first year, and the first few members set the temperature. A mood is catching in a small group: one person who expects the thing to fail will be quoted in every meeting, and one who expects it to grow will be, too. Franklin’s questions were about truth and goodwill, not temper, but a man who loved mankind in general, whatever its profession, was likelier than most to ask another to the Friday meeting.
A group of keepers at the start runs a different course. It has nothing yet to keep, so it keeps what it has, which is its first statement of itself. The Libertarian Party’s pledge was a keeper’s instrument, a guard on the gate, and for fifty years it guarded something real while the membership stayed small. Chapter 50’s warning applies here too. People so concerned with protecting the thing from loss can walk toward the loss by it.
The keepers’ time comes later, and then they matter more than the reachers do. A movement that has grown needs someone to hold the ballot line, remember what was promised, tell the newcomers what the founding was for, and say no to the bad idea that arrives with real momentum. Burke’s partnership among the living, the dead and the unborn was a keeper’s view. The mix shifts with age: mostly reachers at the beginning, because there is little else to do, and more keepers with each year that there’s something to lose.
The hard part is that the founders set the mix for everyone after them. A group that starts with keepers will keep attracting them, and one that starts with reachers will go on attracting reachers, past the point at which it needs the other kind.
Committees
Samuel Adams, in November 1772, persuaded the Boston town meeting to appoint a committee of correspondence, twenty-one men, to state the rights of the colonists and send the statement to every town in Massachusetts. The towns answered, and within two years there were committees in most of the colonies. What spread was a form. A committee needed three or four people, a pen, a messenger and a town willing to read its letter. The form did not require that its members be famous, rich or even of one mind about independence, and for a few years the committees held in the same net men who would shortly be on opposite sides of the war. It’s a different arrangement from the pledge. The committees took people who would do the work of correspondence and left their opinions to be worked out in the letters.
That is the third way to look at early members: neither as the faithful nor as a crowd, but as people who show up for a task and stay for the company it brings. A group formed around a task can afford to be varied, because the task is what the members hold in common. A group formed around a pledge has to hope its members stay alike.
What the Junto did
By the time Franklin was forty, the club’s members had started a subscription library, the Library Company of 1731, out of the same Friday talk, because some of them couldn’t afford the books they argued about. A dozen years later, he proposed the American Philosophical Society, to keep up a correspondence among the curious in all the colonies. It outlived him, and it still meets in Philadelphia. The Junto itself ran for almost forty years. By Franklin’s own account, it ended when its members had gone on to organizations of their own.
Franklin’s twelve were not a movement and never claimed to be. They were a few people chosen for what they would bring to a table and what they would leave out of it, and the habit they took from it, of making a library when a member needed a book, went with them to places Franklin never visited.
A caucus like the Social Liberty Caucus has a step between signing up and being counted, a pending line in the admin until somebody approves it. The step is small, and the Junto’s was smaller still. It was one question put to one person, standing, with eleven others listening.
Sources
- Benjamin Franklin, The Autobiography (written 1771–1790), on the Junto’s members, its rules, and its offshoots, and “Rules for a Club Established for Mutual Improvement” (1731)
- Ernst Mayr, Systematics and the Origin of Species (1942), on founder populations
- Samuel Adams and the Boston Committee of Correspondence, The Votes and Proceedings of the Freeholders and Other Inhabitants of the Town of Boston (1772)
- David Nolan, accounts of the Libertarian Party’s founding in Colorado, 1971
- Social Liberty Foundation, Cultures of Life and Death, Valuing the Culture of Death, Rebranding a Borrowed Line and Debates Within, Mises Versus Hayek
- American Liberty Party, So What’s the Plan?
A note on how this piece was written: the thesis and direction of this essay are mine. The historical examples, sources, and sentences were drafted with AI assistance from that direction, with quotations and dates still to be checked against their sources, and then edited by hand. I’d rather say that plainly than have a reader guess at it.