Social LibertySocial Liberty

Power of Mind over Mind

In 1791 Jeremy Bentham published a prison designed for watching inmates and wrote a case for watching rulers. A government seen in full, citizens left unseen, and candid deliberation are three goods, and every disclosure law gives up some of one.

Social Liberty Foundation ·

Click to enlarge

In 1791 Jeremy Bentham published Panopticon; or, The Inspection-House, a design for a circular prison with an inspector’s lodge at its center, from which every cell could be seen and from which the inspector himself could not be. The inmate, never knowing whether he was observed, would behave as if he always were. Bentham called it “a new mode of obtaining power of mind over mind, in a quantity hitherto without example.” In the same years he was writing An Essay on Political Tactics, a guide to how a legislature should conduct itself, and its second chapter, “Of Publicity,” argued that a legislature’s proceedings should be open to everyone. Those who hold power face more temptations than anyone, he wrote, and against them there is no check more constant and universal than the watchfulness of the public, a tribunal more powerful than all the others together.

It was one idea, pointed two ways. Visibility disciplines whoever is seen. Aimed at the prisoner, it is the instrument of control, and aimed at the minister, the instrument of liberty. The question of whether transparency makes a society freer turns largely on which way the lodge faces, and in practice it rarely faces only one way.

Three goods

From Time to Time followed California’s efforts this year to show where public money goes. Behind those bills sit three things a free society wants, and they don’t fit together.

The first is a visible government, one whose spending, contracts and decisions can be seen by those who pay for them. The second is unseen citizens, whose associations, donations and private letters aren’t the government’s business. The third is candid deliberation, the ability of officials and citizens to talk a question through, try out bad ideas and change their minds before anything is decided. Any two can be had together. Each pair costs some of the third.

A visible government with unseen citizens gives up candid deliberation. The Constitutional Convention met behind closed doors in Philadelphia, its delegates sworn to secrecy. Decades later Madison told the historian Jared Sparks that no constitution would ever have been adopted by the convention if the debates had been public. Delegates changed positions all summer, and a man who has argued for a thing in front of his constituents finds it hard to be seen giving it up. California’s Brown Act opened local government meetings in 1953, and deliberation moved. Council members polled one another by phone, staff carried positions from one member to the next, and the courts had to decide, as in Stockton Newspapers v. Redevelopment Agency in 1985, that a chain of private conversations reaching a majority was itself a meeting. The law can follow deliberation, but each time it does, the talk that mattered has already moved somewhere else.

A visible government with candid deliberation gives up unseen citizens. If what persuades a lawmaker is to be public, so are those who did the persuading. That is the case for posting the position letters Sacramento keeps in its portal, and it’s a strong one. It also lands on everyone who writes. In 1956 Alabama demanded the NAACP’s membership lists, and in NAACP v. Alabama two years later the Supreme Court refused to let it have them, holding that “inviolability of privacy in group association may in many circumstances be indispensable to preservation of freedom of association.” In 2021, in Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta, the Court struck down California’s own demand that charities file the names of their major donors with the attorney general. A trade association can absorb being named. A tenants’ group writing against its landlord’s project, or a parish writing on a bill its bishop opposes, may not write at all.

Unseen citizens with candid deliberation give up a visible government. That is roughly Sacramento’s position-letter portal as it stands, open to lawmakers and closed to the public, defended in the language of privacy and cost. Deliberation is free and writers are protected, and a voter can’t see who asked for what.

No disclosure law escapes the triangle. Each picks a point inside it, and the argument over any one bill is an argument over which of the three goods to spend.

Who reads it

A second problem lives inside the first good. Visibility helps those who look, and looking is work. The audits that SB 1126 will put online from 2028, the Legislative Analyst’s report on tax credits, the salary tables at Transparent California and the payroll charts at TransparentCities.org: each is open to anyone, and each is read most closely by those with a standing reason to read it. A building trades council reads every capital plan in its county. A parent reads one, the year the school bond is on the ballot. Disclosure meant to arm the public can end up arming the most organized part of it, which already had the most influence.

What the public reads is less data than a story drawn from it. Heather Knight’s column on Noe Valley’s $1.7 million toilet, which We Asked for a Park retold, moved the city in weeks where years of posted budgets had not. Transparency serves liberty to the degree someone outside the organized interests turns the record into something a resident can follow.

Legibility

The third problem is the oldest. James C. Scott’s Seeing Like a State traced how rulers made their subjects legible: permanent surnames, cadastral surveys, standard measures, straight-rowed forests. Each made a people visible from the capital, and each was a precondition for taxing, conscripting or resettling them. What the state can see, it can manage, and what it can manage from far away, it tends to.

Spending transparency is legibility pointed the other way, the citizen reading the state, but the records it creates are read by more than citizens. A city that publishes how its Public Works department ranks projects has produced a document a state agency can audit, then set standards for, then replace with a formula. California has done this to housing: the state’s regional housing numbers and its certification of each city’s housing element began as planning documents and became the means by which Sacramento overrides local zoning. Making local government visible to residents can make it visible to the capital too, and local discretion is often the first thing a capital takes once it can see it.

Seen whole

Albert Hirschman’s Exit, Voice, and Loyalty named the two things a member can do when an organization disappoints. He can leave, or he can complain. Transparency strengthens voice. It does little for exit, and where exit is easy, a citizen needs less of it. A resident of a small town can see most of what the council does by attending, and if it goes badly, the next town is close. A resident of a state of forty million, or of a city whose Public Works budget runs through a dozen funds and districts, can’t leave cheaply, and has to see through documents what he can’t see whole.

That suggests the demand for transparency rises with size and distance, and that the most reliable form of it is a government small enough to need little. It also suggests why disclosure laws accumulate in large polities without seeming to satisfy anyone. Each one illuminates a piece of something too large to be looked at directly.

Madison kept his notes of the convention’s secret debates for more than fifty years. He arranged for them to be published after his death, and he was the last of the delegates to die, in 1836. The Madison Papers appeared in 1840. Every argument from that summer became visible, the bad ideas and the reversals with the rest, once nobody who had made them could be held to them. Bentham’s inspection house was never built. Parliament abandoned the project and in 1813 paid him £23,000 for his trouble.


Sources

  • Jeremy Bentham, Panopticon; or, The Inspection-House (1791), in The Works of Jeremy Bentham, ed. Bowring, vol. 4, Online Library of Liberty
  • Jeremy Bentham, An Essay on Political Tactics, ch. 2, “Of Publicity,” in Works, vol. 2, Online Library of Liberty
  • Jared Sparks, journal entry of April 19, 1830, Teaching American History
  • Ralph M. Brown Act, California Government Code §54950 et seq.; Stockton Newspapers, Inc. v. Redevelopment Agency (1985) 171 Cal.App.3d 95
  • NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Patterson, 357 U.S. 449 (1958)
  • Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta, 594 U.S. 595 (2021)
  • CalMatters, What are they trying to hide? California lawmakers kill lobbying transparency bills
  • James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed (Yale, 1998)
  • Albert O. Hirschman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty (Harvard, 1970)
  • James Madison, The Papers of James Madison, ed. Henry D. Gilpin (1840)

A note on how this piece was written: every argument, source, and structural decision in this essay is ours. We chose the examples, worked out the logic connecting them, and directed what each paragraph needed to say. The sentences themselves were drafted with AI assistance from that outline and then edited by hand.

Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X

Featured in Social Liberty Caucus