Problems of Decentralization
Murray Bookchin on why decentralization, localism and self-sufficiency each guarantee nothing: feudal villages, Plato's Republic, and Barcelona's factories after July 1936.
Click to enlarge
Murray Bookchin spent decades arguing for decentralized, face-to-face politics, and he is also among its sharpest critics on one point: the ecology movement's habit of treating small and local as good in themselves. Here is the case he made, in our words.
Two blindnesses sit opposite each other. Pragmatic people overlook why decentralism matters at all. Many in the ecology movement overlook the real problems of localism, which are no smaller than those of a globalism that ties economic and political life together across the whole world. A localism that stresses isolation and self-sufficiency, without wider changes in culture and politics, can slide into parochialism and chauvinism. That is as serious as a global mentality that flattens the differences between cultures, ecosystems and regions, and it threatens the same thing: a community scaled to humans, where people can govern themselves directly. Bookchin's own aim was a way of sharing the world with other people and with other forms of life, and that is hard to find in a community built around doing without outsiders.
Self-reliance, he allowed, has sense in it. If a community can make what it needs, it probably should, and he agreed with David Morris of the Institute for Local Self-Reliance on that much. But a community cannot make everything it needs, unless it goes back to a village life that wore out its men and women early and left little time for politics beyond the village. Some in the movement do argue for that return, a labor-intensive economy and even Stone Age gods. Bookchin thought localism, decentralism and self-sustainability deserved a fuller meaning. A modern society can produce the basic means of life, and more, if it concentrates on useful goods made well.
Others in the movement end up with a collective capitalism, where one community acts as a single entrepreneur, holding its resources as proprietor. A web of cooperatives like that starts a market again. Contracts and bookkeeping creep in, each community counting what it will receive for what it delivers, and the exact-measure logic he called bourgeois right takes over. He pointed to Barcelona after July 1936, when workers took over factories and some of them began running them like capitalist firms, a drift the anarcho-syndicalist CNT resisted early in the Spanish Revolution.
His central warning: neither decentralization nor self-sufficiency is democratic in itself. Plato's Republic was meant to be self-sufficient, and that was what let it maintain a warrior and philosopher elite, with a guard against outside influence like Sparta's. Medieval feudalism, in Europe and in Asia, rested on decentralized communities and still had rigid hierarchy at every level. Small is not necessarily beautiful. For centuries people lived in villages and small towns, with close social ties and sometimes common property, and those villages were the material base for despotic empires in India and China. They suited a no-growth economist's ideal, and they fed the great Oriental despotisms. What they dreaded, nearly as much as armies, was the imperial tax collector.
Anyone who admires such communities for being small, self-sufficient or decentralized has to set aside how stagnant many were and how easily outside elites ruled them. Their tradition-bound division of labor, which looked organic, could harden into caste, as it did in India, where caste still shapes social life.
Taken one at a time, decentralization, localism, self-sufficiency and even confederation guarantee nothing. Each has at some point carried parochial communities, oligarchies and despotic regimes. Only together, and inside institutions that give the terms their content, do they offer a free and ecological society.
This post is a paraphrase of Bookchin's argument. The words are ours, and any errors in them are too.
Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X
Featured in Municipal Social Liberty