Better Myths for Public Good
Society is made up of millions of individuals with conflicting values, priorities, and preferences.
Click to enlarge
Say a town builds eight pickleball courts at the edge of its largest park. There is a ribbon and a photograph, and a statement from the council that the courts are a new recreational amenity for residents, in a sport that is among the fastest growing in the country. Every word of it is true. The statement leaves out that the courts stand on a strip of woodland between the parking lot and the creek, where a man had walked each morning for twenty years, and where a girl had learned the names of the trees.
Nobody at the ribbon-cutting is lying. The benefit has names: the players who signed the petition, the club that asked for the courts, the councilmember who carried the item. The loss has none. A person who walks in a wood owns no pass, belongs to no club and isn’t on any list. The walkers were never a group until the trees were gone, and a group that doesn’t exist can’t testify. The sum the council did was correct on its own terms, and the terms counted only those who could be counted.
Joseph Schumpeter, in 1942, said there was no uniquely determined common good that all people could agree on or be made to agree on, because a society is millions of individuals with conflicting values, priorities and preferences, and what one of them counts as a good another counts as a harm. The Public Choice economists who followed him added that those who invoke the public good are rarely a neutral party, since a subsidy or a regulation defended in its name tends to serve whoever is best organized to ask for it. A second line comes from economics. Paul Samuelson defined a public good in 1954 as one that many can use without using it up and none can be kept from, and the Austrian school, Hans-Hermann Hoppe among them, answered that value is judged by each person, that nothing is public or private in itself, and that the definition was drawn to justify a state which already existed. A third comes from the left, which finds the public good a myth for the opposite reason: services called public are handed to private firms, paid for from taxes, and run for profit.
Each of those critiques asks what the phrase means and who profits from saying it. This essay takes the first of them as its premise and asks a different thing. If there is no one public, and a project is a gain for some and a loss for others, what is owed to the others? The pickleball players and the walkers, the dog owners and the neighbors of a railway, are all real, and the habit of speech that makes them one crowd is the part that has to change.
Who the public is
When government takes a house for a road, the Fifth Amendment says it may do so only for public use and only with just compensation, and the owner is paid. The rule is old and sound. It also leaves a gap no one remarks on. The wood belonged to everyone and to no one in particular, so its taking owes nothing to anyone, and the loss is borne by those who happened to use it.
Compensation answers the owner in the one currency a court can count. It pays for the parcel at what a buyer would have given for it, and a house is more than that. Land is where a street’s people know one another, where a child cuts across to a friend’s, where a path has run for forty years because nobody built on it. A taking for a road or a plant removes the house and the shortcut together, and it replaces both with something that cannot be crossed on foot. In 1981 Detroit took a neighborhood called Poletown, some fourteen hundred homes and its churches and shops, so that a car company could have a site, and every owner was paid. The neighbors who were not owners were paid nothing, and the streets they had known were gone.
Access to land is also one of the plainest liberties a person has, to be somewhere without asking leave. It is easy to overlook where the land has always been open, and it shows up when it is closed. Sweden writes it into custom as allemansrätten, the everyman’s right to walk, camp and pick berries on land that someone else owns, so long as the visitor does no harm. Where such a right is absent, each fence a government puts up on land it holds takes a little of a freedom that no ledger lists, and the people who held it are not counted among the owners. The compensation clause protects the one who had a title. It does not reach the many who had a way through.
The Closing of Open Space
The same week this was written, the local news announced that the Palo Alto Baylands will be closed for the king tides. It is not the first time. The open space has been closed (does this make it not open space?) several times in the name of the good of the public, and each time the people who walk there have lost it for the days the notice says, and as if nobody is interested in seeing the public baylands in the high tide conditions (they are).
The water is not chosen, but the closing of open space is, and changing an open space to an open/closed space is not compensated. The notice at the gate is all there is. When the cause is the sea alone, a loss has no one to bring it to. When a decision stands between the tide and the walker, or the scientist or bird group looking to see what birds do in special conditions, the loss has an author, and the people it falls on are entitled to ask who.
A taking is also a transfer of use. A piece of land that served many purposes at once, a path, a shade, a place for children, a view from a neighbor’s window, a corridor for birds, is turned into land that serves one. The road serves those who drive and the court serves those who play, and every other use the ground had is closed to make room for it. The compensation clause describes the event as a bargain between a government and an owner. The larger exchange is between the many who used the ground in different ways and the one group that will use it in a single way, with the government as the broker, and the clause has no place on its form for the losing side.
The words “public good” do the work of hiding the gap. A good is public when it is available to the public, and a pickleball court is available to those who play pickleball. The word slides from some of the public to the public, and a project defended on those terms looks as if it served everyone and took from no one. The Myth of the Public Steward took up the same habit of speech from the side of the official who is said to hold the land in trust. Here the question is the one the trust is supposed to answer: what became of those who lost, and who is looking after them?
Pickleball players are not the villains of this story. Something like twenty million Americans played the game in 2024, and they wanted somewhere to do it. The town was right to help find them space. It was not right to describe the space that was used by all the people before them as free.
The line down the Peninsula
A larger and slower case runs through the San Francisco Peninsula. A railway opened between San Francisco and San Jose in 1864, and it was a public good in every sense the phrase can carry. Towns grew up at its stations, and farmers could ship to the city, and someone in Menlo Park could be in San Francisco by lunch. The line was built before most of the houses beside it, so those who later settled near it bought with its sound in their ears and its use in their plans.
The line did not stop at that. It was kept going through the Southern Pacific years and into Caltrain’s, and it now carries commuters at a frequency its builders would have found astonishing, with electric trains since 2024. It runs through some forty-two places where a road crosses the tracks at street level. At each, a gate comes down and a horn sounds, and a town that was once one place is two, with a wait between them. Caltrain’s own estimate, drawn from a county grand jury report, puts the cost of lifting or lowering every one of those crossings at between $8.5 billion and $11.1 billion.
The towns have spent years on the question. Menlo Park has studied quiet zones for its four crossings, and Palo Alto has debated a viaduct, a trench and a set of lowered roads, none of which leaves the neighbors alone. One option for south Palo Alto, discussed in 2024, would take more than two dozen properties, and a raised structure was rejected by most of the council over what it would do to the view. The households with the most to lose are the ones nearest the tracks, who are the same households the line has already been wearing on for decades, and the households that gain are riders in towns up and down the line who will never hear a horn or see a viaduct.
No one in this account wants the railway torn up, and no one should. A line that takes thousands off the freeway is a gain, and the commuters are as real as the neighbors. What marks the case is the absence of a ledger. For a hundred and fifty years the gain was counted in riders, and the cost went uncounted in the sleep, the quiet and the crossing times of the people who lived within earshot. It reached the council only when the sums for a bridge made it unavoidable. The line was kept going and the damage was left where it fell.
Responses to it have the name of mitigation, in the current sense: a sound wall, a quiet zone, a study. Each reduces an impact to a number the project can live with. None gives back what was taken, which was a quiet evening, an easy walk to a friend’s house across the tracks, and a town of a single piece.
What mitigate used to mean
The word is older and plainer than its use in a planning document. To mitigate, from the Latin mitigare, is to make mild, to soften a blow or a penalty or a pain. A judge mitigates a sentence. In the older sense, a body that takes one thing from a person softens the loss by giving something of the same kind elsewhere, so the person is not simply poorer. A town that fells a wood for courts, on that standard, owes its walkers a wood.
Today’s use runs the other way. A project is mitigated when its harm is measured and a payment or a barrier set against it, and the sum, so long as it balances on paper, is called neutral. What the older meaning asks for is harder, and more interesting. It asks that the person who lost a place to walk be able to walk somewhere, and not merely that the loss be priced.
That standard seems expensive, and in building it often is. A wood is not replaced by planting a different one, and a railway’s quiet is not restored by a billion dollars of concrete. There is another half of what government does, though, and it costs less.
What government can do by taking away
A government has two instruments with respect to land it holds. It can build, which costs money, takes ground, and needs hearings. Palo Alto has promised its dogs more room since 2016 and, by the count in Palo Alto’s Problem With Dogs, has set aside about an acre and a half, a little at a time.
The building has its own price. By the figure we were given, one of those fenced areas cost the city $600,000 to make, for a small yard that dog owners call a poor one, and in the end many people lost their park. Outside the Parks and Recreation Commission hardly anyone noticed the spending, because park budgets are not written to be read by the public. What people noticed was the result, ugly fenced areas going up beside Adobe Creek. The grass that had been open to anyone, dogs or no dogs, was fenced and surfaced for a single use, and the public that had been using the ground the day before was told it had been improved.
Look at what a government does for a park today and the list is nearly all addition. It builds courts and a restroom, lays a paved path, puts up a fence and a sign, sets a closing hour and a leash rule, and hires someone to enforce them. Each is done for the park, and each is also done to it. The courts end a wood, the path ends a meadow’s wildness, the closing hour ends the night walk, and the leash rule ends the dog’s run. A park managed this way gets more finished every year and, to the person who used it for what it was, worse. The finishing is almost always called improvement, and there is rarely anyone positioned to say what it cost.
Or it can withhold, which costs nothing.
Take a parcel of public land forty acres wide, a square of thirteen hundred and twenty feet on each side, and decide that no one will enforce the leash law there. No fence goes up, no budget line is drawn, and no one need attend a hearing. A sign at the edge says that dogs may run. That is the entire act, and it gives something real: a place where a dog can cross a field at a run and its owner can walk behind it. A government that has forty acres to spare, and most do, has by not doing something set aside a piece of the world for those who wanted it.
The loss of the wood, in a town that took the walkers’ path for a court, would then have an answer that fits it. The walker who loses the woodland is not owed the same trees. She is owed a place of her own kind, and a government that holds enough land can decide, by writing less law and not more, that a stretch of it is hers: no courts and no amplified sound, a place to wander and to forage and to stand in quiet. The forty acres for dogs and the forty for the walker cost the same, which is a decision not to enforce or build.
The method has limits, and the choice of ground matters. A field beside a heron rookery is the wrong place for running dogs. A parcel too small for the group it is meant for will fail them. The principle survives all of these, because it was never that every use fits everywhere. It was that a government which takes a thing away from some citizens should be able to say where the thing went when they moved it there.
A vast mosaic
A myth, in the sense that matters here, is the story a people tell about what their shared holdings are for. The old story is of one public with one interest, served by a rule or a building that is good for all of it, and its flaw is that the story can’t see its own losers. A better story is a mosaic. It keeps the idea that shared land should serve everyone, and drops the idea that a single use of it can.
Seen across a whole park, or a whole county, the pattern that results is not one rule but many, laid side by side. Here is a field where dogs run free, and next to it a stand of trees where they don’t. Here are eight courts, and past them a meadow where nothing is allowed that makes a noise. One square belongs to the walker with a field guide and another to the child with a stick. The rules are posted at the edge and the squares are small enough to cross on foot, so that a person who dislikes one can walk to the next.
Everyone is served by some part of it, which a single rule written for the average user of a park cannot manage, because the average user doesn’t exist. The leash rule that keeps a walker who is nervous around dogs comfortable is the one that costs the dog its run, and each rule, taken alone for the whole park, takes from one citizen to give to another. A mosaic lets the taking and the giving stay in the same place, so that nobody has to be the one who loses everywhere.
That is the better myth, and what makes it better is the mosaic itself. The phrase public good would stop meaning something done for a crowd with a petition and would mean a holding in which every person, looking across the whole of it, can find a corner of their own. A project in such a story has to say what it takes and where the taken thing now lives, and the answer to the walkers at the ribbon-cutting is a place on the map.
A way back
People live inside stories about what government is and does, and today they do so almost entirely. The public good, the public interest and the public steward are not descriptions of anything one could point to. They are a vocabulary in which a ribbon-cutting and a railway read as the same kind of event, a gain for everyone, and the vocabulary is what is shared when people argue about what to build. Telling people to drop it and look at the ground is not likely to work, since nobody argues from the ground. They argue from a story.
A better story is therefore a way back, and a more modest one than a demand to see things as they are. Interfaces described a transition as something that moves through an interface, one step at a time, with each step small enough to be taken from where people stand. The mosaic is such a step. It leaves the language of public good in place and adds a requirement that the language can’t satisfy on its own terms: say where. Where is the wood the courts replaced, and where is the quiet the line took, and where can the dog run? A myth that has to answer in places can be checked against places, and a person standing in a field can tell whether the answer was true.
The old myth never had to meet that test, because everyone is not a location. The new one does, and each time it is asked the story moves a little closer to the map and farther from the speech. Nothing in the approach requires anyone to give up the idea of a public. It asks the public to be somewhere in particular.
The pickleball courts stay where they are. A hundred yards off, on a stretch of grass nobody has fenced, a man is walking in the early light with his dog unleashed, and the dog has gone ahead without anyone at the other end of the strap. A woman crosses the far path toward the trees with a notebook in her hand, and neither needs the other to move.
Sources
- Joseph A. Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942), part IV, on the “common good” and the will of the people
- Paul A. Samuelson, “The Pure Theory of Public Expenditure,” Review of Economics and Statistics (1954); Hans-Hermann Hoppe, “Fallacies of the Public-Goods Theory and the Production of Security,” Journal of Libertarian Studies (1989)
- Demos, “Reimagining Public Goods”; Protean Magazine, “The Myth of the Public Good” (2022), for the left critique of privatized public provision
- U.S. Constitution, Fifth Amendment (takings clause); Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit, 410 Mich. 616 (1981)
- Swedish allemansrätten (the right of public access), as described by the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency
- Sports & Fitness Industry Association and Association of Pickleball Professionals, 2024 pickleball participation reports
- Caltrain, Corridor Crossings Strategy (caltrain.com/ccs), including the 2026 update on safety and grade-separation programs
- San Mateo County Civil Grand Jury, report on Peninsula grade separations (2018 to 2019), source of the $8.5 to $11.1 billion estimate for 42 at-grade crossings
- City of Palo Alto, Rail Grade Separation project pages and Grade Separation FAQs; Palo Alto Online, “Residents rail against property takings in Palo Alto” (30 April 2024)
- City of Menlo Park, Caltrain Quiet Zone Project; Almanac, “Menlo Park council splinters on grade separations” (11 October 2017)
- Margaret Johannsen, Palo Alto’s Problem With Dogs, on the 1.6 acres of legal off-leash ground and the delay since 2016
- Oxford English Dictionary, “mitigate” (from Latin mitigare)
A note on how this piece was written: the subject, the argument that a public good has to account for what it takes, the older sense of mitigation, and the idea of a mosaic of unenforced and enforced squares are ours. The sentences were drafted with AI assistance from that direction and then edited by hand. The pickleball town is a composite and not a real place, and the railway dates and figures, the 2024 electrification, the Palo Alto property count and the $600,000 cost of a Palo Alto dog area, with the park it displaced, are still to be checked against the sources, along with the local-news item on the Baylands closings, the Poletown figures and the summaries of Schumpeter, Hoppe and the left critique in the opening.