Social LibertySocial Liberty

Liberty for Thee

Fourteen hundred dollars a month, eight hundred of it to a landlord, and a back that will hold no job. A two-thousand-dollar savings cap unchanged since 1989, Paine's "not charity but a right," and what such a person is to a liberty caucus.

Kevin Carl ·

Click to enlarge

Ray is a composite, drawn from several people, and no one of them is Ray. The numbers are real ones.


The deposit lands on the third of the month. Ray knows the hour his bank app refreshes, and he’s checked it the way some people check a pulse.

Fourteen hundred dollars. Eight hundred leaves for the apartment before the afternoon is out, which leaves six hundred for food, a phone, the bus, a pharmacy co-pay, and whatever the month turns up.

Ray hurt his back lifting something heavy at work years ago, and it healed into a shape that doesn’t allow sitting past forty minutes or lifting a gallon of milk without a plan. Two doctors and a hearing agreed there was no job in it. The check is survival.

A look at the rent first. A tenant in public housing, or one holding a voucher, pays about thirty percent of income. Thirty percent of fourteen hundred is four-twenty. Eight hundred is closer to fifty-seven percent, and that points to a different kind of unit, one built with tax credits, where the rent is set by the building’s tier and not by what the tenant earns.

Ray is subsidized, in the sense that somebody built the building cheaply, and he is not protected, in the sense that the rent doesn’t fall if his income does. Twice this year a knob broke on the old stove, and this is the third time this year he has had to sit at a legal hearing with the company managing the property.

What does Ray think about liberty?

What the libertarian message sounds like

The standard version of it, the one the Libertarian Party has carried for fifty years and the Mises Caucus carried louder, says taxation is theft and the welfare state is its main exhibit. People should keep what they earn, give what they choose, and trust neighbors and charities to catch whoever falls.

Said from a podium, it is a clean idea.

Said in Ray’s hearing, Ray IS the welfare state, and the message is a list of what he’s about to lose.

He has no way to know whether the theoretical neighbors and charities will arrive, and the check arrives on the third. A message that begins by promising to abolish the check can’t get past the first sentence with him, and he isn’t being stubborn about it. Anyone with a rent due will stop listening there.

If that were the whole story, the essay would end right now, with Ray filed under the people liberty can’t reach. Libertarianism that is wholly a theoretical idea, without a teaspoon of compassion for people like these, stays small.

What he knows that the podium doesn’t

Ray lives inside the thing the podium is describing, and few people alive know its working parts better.

Ray’s check is the kind that depends on need. He can hold no more than two thousand dollars in assets. The figure was set in 1989 and has never been raised, so it has lost more than half its buying power.

A birthday gift from a sister goes against it.

A car worth more than the rules allow goes against it.

A modest savings for a bad winter, the thing every adviser tells everyone to have, is the one thing the rules treat as grounds for a cut.

If he tries to work an hour or two a week, some payment shrinks as his earnings rise, and past a limit he loses the check and the health coverage that comes with it. Then he has to prove his back hurts all over again to get them back.

A letter arrives asking him to confirm his circumstances. An inspector comes to look at the apartment. Each is a small interruption, and the sum of them is a life lived under permission: whom he may live with, what he may keep, what he may try.

That’s the state a liberty movement opposes. It is also the state Ray lives with every month, written in letters.

Three claims

First, the check is what holds him up. Housing, food and a roof over a back that won’t carry weight depend on it. Taking it away in the name of freedom leaves him less free in every way.

Second, the check comes with a cage built around it. Asset limits, earnings cliffs, recertifications, inspections. A framework that protects him also decides what he may own.

Third, a message that threatens the first claim will never get to the second. No one will hear about the cage from a movement that has just promised to take away the floor.

An older answer

Thomas Paine had a version of this in 1797. Agrarian Justice proposed that every person at twenty-one receive a sum from a fund, and that every person past fifty receive a yearly payment, with the lame and the blind provided for. He drew the fund from a tax on inherited land, and he said plainly what the payment was and wasn’t: “It is not charity but a right, not bounty but justice, that I am pleading for.”

A right, not a favor. The same payment under another name is a dole, and the people receiving it are petitioners, in line for something that can be taken back. A payment owed by the land’s former commoners to everyone has none of that. Ray will not need to prove his back hurts, because the payment doesn’t turn on it.

Hayek, no one’s idea of a socialist, put the floor in The Road to Serfdom in 1944. “Some minimum of food, shelter, and clothing, sufficient to preserve health and the capacity to work,” he wrote, could be assured to everybody, and he thought a free society could afford it without any loss of freedom. What he opposed was a state that rationed the rest.

What a caucus has for him

A person in Ray’s position is a stranger to most political groups. He is a case study to the left and a cautionary tale to the right, and he is something to be talked about more often than something to be talked with.

Here is what he has that a young caucus lacks. He has hours, more than anyone with a job. He has an education he hasn’t discarded, and a good deal of it came from places a pension never reached: Jethro Tull on a turntable, a flute he can play sitting down, a kitchen table covered in paint.

He has a working knowledge of how an administrative state looks from beneath, which is what a movement about permission ought to want most, and which almost none of its members can give. A caucus that takes a hundred of its policy ideas to Ray will hear which of them survive a month on six hundred dollars.

First There Was One, Then There Were Two asked what a small group’s early members do to its character: it needs enough of them, enough alike, and enough different. Ray is the difference. A caucus of people who have never needed anything from the state will talk to itself with great consistency.

What does the person on the third of the month think about liberty? What he thinks about any offer: does it ask him to put the check at risk? A message that says plainly it won’t, and that the cage built around it is the part to take apart, is one he can hear to the end.

On the third, after the deposit posts, Ray puts the kettle on, props the canvas against the wall, and picks up the flute to play for as long as his back lets him sit.

Earlier, the essay nearly ended with Ray filed under the people liberty can’t reach.

That file shouldn’t exist.

A movement that is complete has no such drawer. Every person it can’t speak to is a sentence it hasn’t finished, and the ones it can’t speak to first are the people it owes the most attention.

Ray isn’t unreachable. He is waiting to hear the part of the message that has him in it.


Sources

  • Social Security Administration, Understanding Supplemental Security Income: Resources, on the $2,000 individual resource limit
  • U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, rent in public housing and the Housing Choice Voucher program (about thirty percent of adjusted income), and the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program
  • Thomas Paine, Agrarian Justice (1797)
  • F. A. Hayek, The Road to Serfdom (1944), chapter IX, “Security and Freedom”
  • Social Liberty Foundation, First There Was One, Then There Were Two, Rebranding a Borrowed Line and Debates Within, Mises Versus Hayek

A note on how this piece was written: the thesis and direction of this essay are mine. Ray is a composite and the arithmetic is real. The sentences and sources were drafted with AI assistance from that direction, with quotations and program figures still to be checked against their sources, and then edited by hand. I’d rather say that plainly than have a reader guess at it.

Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X