Founders
An org chart for the Social Liberty Caucus at twelve people: a convener, two wing leads, three keepers and six workstream seats, with who reports to whom and who must be asked first.
Click to enlarge
Working draft. Seats, not names: each box below is a job, and one person fills it. Nobody holds two until there are fewer than twelve people.
First There Was One, Then There Were Two argued that the first dozen members set the character of everyone after them, and that the Junto and the committees of correspondence worked because each member came for a task. Inside the Liberty Corner gave the caucus two wings. This chart puts both into twelve seats.
The first twelve seats. Solid lines show who reports to whom, dashed lines show who co-signs or is consulted.
Why these twelve
Mostly reachers. Eight seats are for people who go toward a gap, three are for people who stand in front of what has been made, and the Convener has to be both. The essay’s reasoning was that at twelve there is little yet to guard and a great deal to grow, so the mix leans toward reach. Each seat carries a task, in the manner of the committees of correspondence, and nobody is asked to sign a statement of belief first.
Keepers who hold the record. The Clerk, the Treasurer and the Site steward are the three seats whose work is to keep something intact: the roll, the books, the data. They come in at the start because those records are cheap to keep from the first day and expensive to reconstruct later. The members directory is already an approval queue in the admin, so the Site steward has a real job on day one.
Two wings, one chart. The wing leads are the only seats defined by whom they face and not by what they do. They sit beside the Convener, not under a workstream, because a position taken in a party’s vocabulary needs both of them to sign before it is the caucus’s. Each of the other nine seats works with one wing more than the other, and the right-hand column of the table says which, but none reports to a wing lead.
Pairs, not departments. The six workstream seats come in three pairs, Reach, Convene and Build, so that no job is held by one person alone and every pair has a lead with a direct line to the Convener. A pair is also the smallest group that can disagree. That makes the Convener’s span five direct lines plus the two co-signing wings, which a single person can run at this size.
Relationships that don’t show on the lines
- Dashed, wing to wing. Neither wing lead can speak alone about a party’s position. A disagreement goes to the Convener, who writes down where the two differ and doesn’t settle it. The chart leaves open what may be owned, and so does the caucus.
- Treasurer and Clerk check each other. Neither is under the other. The Clerk records what the Treasurer reports, and the Treasurer pays only what the minutes show was agreed.
- Membership and the site. Admission is one question put to one person. The Site steward runs the queue and Membership asks the question, and neither approves alone.
- The Convener doesn’t hold a workstream. The seat rotates, and a rotating seat that also ran the conference or the ballot work would carry them out the door each year.
The seats
| # | Seat | Kind | Remit | Reports to | Works most with |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Convener | both | Chairs the table, breaks ties, speaks for the caucus once the wings have signed. First among equals, rotating yearly. | The table (all twelve) | Both wing leads |
| 2 | Progressive-wing lead | reacher | Faces Democratic voters and officeholders: municipalists, geolibertarians, bleeding-heart and left-libertarians. | Convener | Municipal kit, Regions |
| 3 | Conservative-wing lead | reacher | Faces Republican voters and officeholders: fusionists, paleolibertarians, libertarian conservatives, Christian libertarians. | Convener | Ballot and candidates, Regions |
| 4 | Clerk | keeper | Bylaws, the member roll, minutes, what was promised. Holds the record the later members will be told the founding was for. | Convener | Site steward, Treasurer |
| 5 | Treasurer | keeper | Dues, filings and the books. Reports spending to all twelve, not only the Convener. | Convener | Clerk, Ballot and candidates |
| 6 | Site steward | keeper | The website, the members directory, backups. | Clerk | Membership, Correspondence |
| 7 | Membership | reacher, Reach lead | Admits members, asks the one question, works the pending line, brings in the next friend. | Convener | Site steward, both wing leads |
| 8 | Correspondence | reacher | The essays, the feed, the Discord announcements: the committee’s letters. | Membership | Conference, both wing leads |
| 9 | Conference | reacher, Convene lead | Social Liberty 2027: the call for proposals, the track chairs, the closing caucus agenda. | Convener | Correspondence, Regions |
| 10 | Regions | reacher | The nine regional councils and the first pilot region. | Conference | Both wing leads |
| 11 | Ballot and candidates | reacher, Build lead | Fusion lines, signatures, filings, who runs where. | Convener | Treasurer, conservative-wing lead |
| 12 | Municipal kit | reacher | The kit a member can run in their own town. | Ballot and candidates | Progressive-wing lead |
Outside counsel is shown on the chart as a dashed box. It is not a seat, since a filing or a contract will need a lawyer before it needs a thirteenth member.
Open questions
- Is a yearly rotation too fast for a group this young, or too slow if the first Convener turns out to be the wrong temperament?
- Should the Treasurer be a keeper at all in year one, if the caucus has no money? The seat could start combined with the Clerk and split at the first filing.
- Who fills the two wing-lead seats first, and does each wing need two of its own people before the other has one?
- Do the nine regions need a named lead each by 2027, or is Regions one seat for the first pilot?
- Should the Convener’s term and the conference date line up, or deliberately not?