Social LibertySocial Liberty

Who Will Work For The Public

A city has nine ways to answer a seller that will not come to the meeting. Sorted into voice, exit and force, they show what social liberty prefers: a referee written into the arrangement, with force kept as the last step and not the goal.

Alan Forester-Kaiser ·

Click to enlarge

Twenty-six Bay Area water agencies, Palo Alto among them, buy their water from San Francisco’s public utility under a contract that runs to 2034. San Francisco plans the system against a drought of 8.5 years, an assumption in place since 1992, and the buyers pay a share of what that plan costs. They have no vote on the assumption. Their own agency, BAWSCA, can ask the seller to review it and cannot make the seller do so, and on November 16, 2026, the seller did not come to Palo Alto’s study session on the subject.

That dispute, and the options Palo Alto has in it, are laid out in Sometimes a Lawsuit is the Best Answer, which ends with a table of nine things the city can do. This essay starts from that table. It asks a different question of the same list: which of the nine would a social liberty frame choose, and why.

The question is a general one. One government sells to another, or regulates it, or plans for it, and the two disagree. No office stands over both, and California has none that mediates between its own governments. The water case is one instance, and the sorting below is meant to hold for others, such as a county and a city, two cities sharing a road, or a district and the state that funds it. The essay stays with the water case for its examples, uses what the contract says there, and does not try to survey other disputes or judge who is right about the drought. Whether the 8.5-year assumption is sound is the water essay’s subject and is left open here. The subject here is what a government may do when it believes another one is wrong, and cannot compel it.

Three kinds of answer

Albert Hirschman, in Exit, Voice, and Loyalty (1970), sorted the ways a member answers an organization that is failing it. A member can leave, which is exit. A member can complain and press for change from inside, which is voice. Or a member can stay quiet and stay, which he called loyalty. The sorting fits the table well, with one addition. Two of the table’s options do neither of his things. They compel, and a third word is needed for them: force.

Voice is the letter BAWSCA sent, the item on the BAWSCA board’s agenda, the call to a state senator, the city’s own analyst. Each is a request.

Exit is the vote not to renew in 2032, and the option to leave BAWSCA. Each changes who the city deals with, and at what price.

Force is arbitration under Section 8.01 and a lawsuit. Each makes the other side answer, and each leaves a loser.

Kind Options from the table What each asks of the seller
Voice Letter asking for a review; BAWSCA board; legislators; own analyst A reply, if it chooses
Exit 2032 renewal vote; leaving BAWSCA Nothing, but it must care that they could go
Force Arbitration (§8.01); lawsuit An answer, in front of someone else
None of the three State mediator Consent, which it has not given

What the frame asks of an arrangement

Social liberty, as this collection uses the word, starts from the observation that liberty is lived inside frameworks, and that a framework is judged by whether the people under it can shape it. A person alone on a ranch is not freer for the absence of rules, since the wire, the boots and the words he thinks in all came from other people. The question is whether the rules answer to the ones who live under them.

Elinor Ostrom tested that question on commons that had lasted, such as the Swiss meadow at Törbel, governed by written rule since 1483. In Governing the Commons (1990) she found a few features that the durable ones share. Those who live under the rules take part in changing them. Conflicts have a cheap, quick place to go. Sanctions begin small and grow. Larger arrangements are built from smaller ones that keep their own say.

Held against that list, the water arrangement shows its gaps. The buyers are most of the use and have no part in changing the assumptions that set the cost. The only place a dispute can go is a contract clause or a court, both slow and costly. The sanction on offer is a suit, which comes in one size. And the buyers’ own agency can speak but not decide.

The frame does not say the buyers should leave the system, which is the individualist’s answer, or that a higher authority should take it over, which is the collectivist’s. It asks for something between: an arrangement in which those affected hold a seat, disputes have a referee, and the steps run from small to large.

Which of the nine, then

Voice, but with standing. A letter that the seller can ignore is not yet voice in the sense the frame wants. The frame prefers voice that comes with a place at the table. A request for an independent review of the design drought carries weight when the contract says who conducts it and what follows. At present it is a courtesy.

Exit, kept credible. Exit matters because it makes voice worth answering, and Hirschman’s point was that exit works as a check when the member could really go. The 2032 renewal vote is the buyers’ most valuable card, and the frame favors playing it as a visible fact, years early, in the open. Leaving BAWSCA is the opposite case. It gives up the one body that holds the buyers’ collective voice, and the council has not been told what it would cost. The frame’s weight is against it, since the buyers’ strength is in being many.

Force, graduated. Ostrom’s sanctions begin small. Arbitration under Section 8.01 is the small one: a single customer can start it, it is binding, and it is built for exactly the dispute over what costs belong in the requirement. A lawsuit is the large one, and the frame treats it as a step in the sequence and not as the aim. A suit that wins a ruling does not give the buyers a seat, and a seat is what the frame asks for. Its best use is to force the seller to show its work, which can make the other steps work.

The state mediator, as a gap. The state has no standing office to mediate between its own governments. The frame reads that as a design flaw to repair and not as a route to use. The seller’s refusal to attend a study session would not matter as much if a referee existed whom both sides had to meet.

The frame shift: from plenty to scarcity

Frameworks used the phrase in the sense Mercury taught it. An anomaly stays where it is, and astronomers working in one framework look for a planet while astronomers in the next find nothing to look for. A new framework doesn’t fill the old one’s slots better. It changes which slots exist. The shift that matters in the water case is of that kind, and it is a different shift from the one the table’s options can reach.

It is the shift from treating water as plentiful to treating it as scarce.

The machinery was cut for plenty. Hetch Hetchy was built for a region that was growing and expected to keep growing, and its institutions took on that shape: the contract promises each buyer a guaranteed supply, and the rate arithmetic divides a requirement by the water the region expects to sell, so that growth in sales tends to lower the price of the rest. A public that sees water as plentiful reads the bill the way it reads any utility bill, as a charge for what comes out of the tap. Its question is how to supply the demand, and the capital plan is the answer.

Scarcity asks another question, which is how to divide a limited amount. The region has already acted on it. Use is under 200 million gallons a day and has been for about twelve years, and its residents cut it under conservation measures. The framework around them has not followed. The same arithmetic that rewarded growth in sales now punishes the shrinking of them, so that the conserving city pays more per unit as its use falls. The contract has the beginning of a scarcity framework in its plan for sharing a shortage of up to twenty percent. The rest of it, the rates and the planning, still stands where plenty put it.

A scarce resource has slots that a plentiful one does not. Someone must decide how big a shortage to plan against, and the design drought is that decision, in place since 1992, and until this month never formally discussed by Palo Alto’s council. Someone must say who bears a cut, and who pays for insurance against one. Someone must be able to check the numbers, with the standing to act on what the check finds. Under plenty nobody was assigned these jobs, since the cost of a mistake was small and fell on no one in particular. Under scarcity the cost of a mistake falls on a particular party, and the party is the buyers, the public they serve, and the water they conserve.

The first to move pays

A frame shift has a habit that proactive progressiveness would not predict. The ones who change first are punished for it. Ignaz Semmelweis showed in 1847 that doctors washing their hands in chlorinated lime cut deaths in a Vienna maternity ward, and the frame he was shifting, in which doctors could not be the carriers, made him a crank. He lost his post and died in an asylum in 1865. The pattern is not confined to medicine. Under the old frame the early mover looks like a deviation, and the structures built for the old frame bill him for it.

The water case has its own version, written into the schedule. When the SFPUC’s commission declares a shortage stage, the rate schedule applies a drought surcharge to its retail customers, and its formula is stated plainly: the surcharge per hundred cubic feet equals the water revenue shortfall from reduced flow, divided by the reduced water flow. A customer who uses less is charged for having used less. The wholesale contract lets the SFPUC adjust wholesale rates in step when it does so, and Palo Alto’s staff told the council that large cutbacks could raise the wholesale rate and trigger local shortage stages and drought surcharges. The same arithmetic runs without any shortage stage in force. A region that saves water sees the price of the remaining water climb, so the saving does not show up in the bill in the proportion it showed up in the pipe.

A framework built for scarcity would run the other way. It would hold a slot in which those who save keep what they saved, and the first to conserve would be the first to gain. A framework built for plenty has no such slot, because under plenty nobody has anything to save.

Who will work for the public

That is where the title’s question comes from. In a framework of plenty, work for the public meant supplying it. In a framework of scarcity, it means standing for the public in a dispute over shares, which requires a seat, a referee and a review whose findings bind. None of these exist in the arrangement now, and the options in the table ask for them one at a time. The renewal of the contract in 2032 to 2034 is the point where a framework can be rewritten and not merely argued with.


Sources

  • Albert O. Hirschman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States (1970)
  • Elinor Ostrom, Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action (1990), on design principles of long-lived commons, including the Törbel meadow
  • California Government Code, Joint Exercise of Powers Act (section 6500 and following)
  • 2021 Amended and Restated Water Supply Agreement between the City and County of San Francisco and the wholesale customers (BAWSCA), sections 2.02, 3.11, 6.03 and 8.01
  • SFPUC, Rate Schedules & Fees for Water and Sewer Service, fiscal years 2026-27 and 2027-28 (water drought surcharge)
  • Ignaz Semmelweis and the Vienna General Hospital maternity wards, 1847 to 1865
  • From this collection: Individual Liberty or Social Liberty, Frameworks and Interfaces

A note on how this piece was written: the thesis and direction are mine. The sentences were drafted with AI assistance from that direction, with the summaries of Hirschman, Ostrom and Semmelweis, the Joint Exercise of Powers Act and the contract provisions still to be checked against their sources, and then edited by hand. I’d rather say that plainly than have a reader guess at it.

Discuss this essay on Discord · Follow us on X